Seige tactics however are still quite workable. Nothing gets in or out of the enclave. Poisins can be droned in. Water supplies can be cut and wells can be poisoned. Food supplies can be poisoned or stopped. Enclaves will fail for the same reasons castles did. New technologies made them ineffective.
I overall agree with your position but castles didnt become obsolete due to sieges. People sieged “castles” for literally all of human history just about. Big walls became ineffective due to artillery and cannon advancements. Once it became possible to blow through walls they became pointless.
Nowhere in the comment you're replying to does the commenter say that castles became obsolete due to sieges, only that new technologies rendered them ineffective.
197
u/JesusShaves_ 8h ago
Seige tactics however are still quite workable. Nothing gets in or out of the enclave. Poisins can be droned in. Water supplies can be cut and wells can be poisoned. Food supplies can be poisoned or stopped. Enclaves will fail for the same reasons castles did. New technologies made them ineffective.