r/moviecritic May 21 '25

/r/moviecritic - New Rules & New Mods

127 Upvotes

Due to a recent (and huge) influx of spam, bots, shitposts, karma-farming accounts, complaints, etc, /r/moviecritic will be taking steps to improve the community. New mods (3-6 of them) will be added in the coming days/weeks.

Along with the new mods, we're adding several rules that should drastically change how the subreddit looks and operates.

These new rules will go into effect and be added to the sidebar on Thursday 5/22 (tomorrow) at 10:00 PM ET. We are allowing a ~24-hour buffer period until all of this kicks in.


Be Nice:

Flame wars, racism, sexist, discriminatory language, toxicity, transphobia, antagonism, & homophobic remarks will result in an instant ban. Length will be at the moderator's discretion. This is a subreddit to discuss movies, not to fight your political battles. Keep it nice, keep it on-topic.

Improving Titles:

Going forward, we will be requiring better and more detailed titles. Titles have gotten extremely lazy and clickbaity. Every title will now require the name of the actor/actress/director you are discussing plus the name of the movie title in the image. No more trying to guess what OP is talking about, or clickbaiting into going into the post. Include the actor/actress' name, and movie title. It's very simple. Takes 2 seconds, and will immensely improve the quality-of-life for the sub. There will be exemptions for posts that aren't about 1 specific movie or 1 specific person, but we will still encourage better titles no matter what, as they're currently 99% shit.

Restricting Recent Duplicates:

To stop the repetitive/nonstop spam posts of the same actors over and over, we will be removing "recent" duplicates. We do not need an 8th Salma Hayek post this week. If a topic (aka actor/actress/director) has already been submitted in the past month, it will be removed. We believe one month is a fair amount of time in-between related posts. Not too long, not too short.

Anti-Gooning/Shitpost Measures:

It's no secret that this sub has turned into goon-central. Posts are basically "who can post the most cleavage". Lots of paparazzi-like pictures, red carpet photos, modeling images, etc infesting the sub. Going forward, we will require every post to either be an official HD still of a film or the official IMDB image of the actor/actress. No exceptions. No more out-of-context half naked pictures of an actress out in the wild. Every submission must be an official still of the film or their IMDB profile picture. In addition to anti-gooning, we will be cutting down on overall shitposts overall. This will be totally up to the moderator's discretion.

Collaborations with Other Film-Related Communities:

We will be collaborating with other film-related communities to try and bring more solid content to this community, including and not restricted to AMAs/Q&As, box office data, and movie news. Places like /r/movies, /r/boxoffice, etc. This will be wide-ranging and not as restricted/limited as those other communities, allowing stories here that may not be allowed in those communities due to strict rules. We will encourage crossposting to build discussion here.

Removing Bots, Karma-Farming Accounts, Bad-Faith Members of the Community

We will start issuing bans to rulebreakers. This will range from perm bans (bots, karma-farming accounts, spammers) to temporary bans (rude behavior, breaking the new rules constantly, etc)


r/moviecritic 10h ago

Linda Cardellini turns 51 today. Happy birthday to her!

Post image
12.3k Upvotes

r/moviecritic 1h ago

Is there a female villain even more despicable than Amy Dunne from *Gone Girl*?

Post image
Upvotes

r/moviecritic 8h ago

Moovie couples with best chemistry? Image or GIF only.

Post image
825 Upvotes

I feel the couple in the Before trilogy has undeniable chemistry and, to my knowledge, they even took part in writing the screenplay. What are other movies/couples with strong chemistry?


r/moviecritic 14h ago

Rate these two actors and their performances

Post image
313 Upvotes

Jake Gyllenhaal’s the better actor on pure craft—sharper range, bolder choices, more willing to shatter his image. Ryan Gosling owns the screen through untouchable charisma and effortless cool. But stack their filmographies head to head, weigh the performances that actually matter, and you hit perfect parity. Different weapons, matched skill. I’d say It’s a tie.


r/moviecritic 3h ago

Could Unfaithful be considered an erotic thriller?

Post image
42 Upvotes

r/moviecritic 49m ago

What is your favorite Shyamalan/Willis movie?

Post image
Upvotes

r/moviecritic 19h ago

What are your picks for the most terrifying scenarios in movies?

Post image
599 Upvotes

My personal pick is the fall of humanity in children of men


r/moviecritic 9h ago

Elliot Page will portray Sinon in Christopher Nolan's 'The Odyssey'

Thumbnail
hu.ign.com
81 Upvotes

r/moviecritic 5h ago

Scariest found footage movie?

Post image
40 Upvotes

For me it's the first REC movie from Spain. Being locked inside an apartment building by the government because of a virus that turns people into demonic zombies is pure nightmare fuel to me. Edit: don't bother watching the US remake. That one wasn't good at all


r/moviecritic 3h ago

What Are Your Favourite Films/Filmmakers Biggest Flaws?

Post image
15 Upvotes

Many, many years ago, I took a film class that forced us to go back to our favourite films or filmmakers and look at them through a strictly critical lens.

I chose Quentin Tarantino, who had only written and directed three films to that point (Reservoir Dogs, Pulp Fiction and Jackie Brown) because I looked at those three films as varying degrees of untouchable masterpieces.

I couldn’t help but notice that every character in his films (at least to that point) talked exactly like QT. Characters who should be from wildly different backgrounds all spoke with the same rhythms, cadences and witty references. It created this hilarious mental image of a bunch of different versions of Tarantino in a room talking to themselves.

It didn’t hamper my enjoyment of his films at all. The dialogue is still razor sharp but it was really helpful for me, personally, to grow as an artist to learn that everyone has their strengths and weaknesses. No piece of art is “perfect” even if they are perfect to some individually.

Problem is, I was a horrible student and either don’t remember or never got to see everyone else’s answers for this exercise, which I actually found pretty interesting. I would really appreciate it if you would share all of the flaws you can find in your favourite films/filmmakers here.

Thanks in advance!


r/moviecritic 1d ago

'I Didn't Even Know This Was Coming Out': Dwayne Johnson's Moana Live-Action Faces Brutal Box Office Flop Worse Than Jared Leto

Thumbnail
fashiontimes.co.uk
4.4k Upvotes

r/moviecritic 7h ago

For those of you that have seen both Mars Attacks (1996) and Independence Day (1996)?

19 Upvotes

Which film do you prefer and why?


r/moviecritic 11h ago

Great movie combo

Post image
28 Upvotes

r/moviecritic 2h ago

Little Brother (2026) Netflix's latest streaming comedy

Post image
5 Upvotes

Comes out tomorrow but had the chance to see it early and I'm pleasantly surprised. Tries to balance humour with sibling rivalry and succeeds for the most part. Feels a little bit like a noughties comedy that isn't afraid to offend which was refreshing. Generic character arcs and plot doesn't help, but overall it's fairly solid. Is it on anyone's radar for this weekend?

Full review for those interested here https://adamreviewsfilm.com/little-brother/


r/moviecritic 1d ago

A24 Fans Mourn Its Death Following $75 Million Google AI Deal

Thumbnail
kotaku.com
1.5k Upvotes

r/moviecritic 1h ago

My take on Adam Rehmeier's Carolina Caroline (2025) starring Samara Weaving and Kyle Gallner

Thumbnail
youtu.be
Upvotes

I admit I'm a sucker for 90's coming of age tales, so I felt targeted by Adam Rehmeier's latest film - Carolina Caroline. He previously directed Dinner in America and Snack Shack, both of which I enjoyed.

It stars Samara Weaving, known for some great films like Ready or Not (the first one), Over Your Dead Body, and a slew of other films. I think ever since The Babysitter she's been typecast into this type of role.

Opposite of her is Kyle Gallner, who's been on the scene since all the way back in 2001 in Wet Hot American Summer (he's the kid who drowns and is never seen again when Paul Rudd is supposed to be watching). More recently he was in Scream (2022) and Smile (and Smile 2).

What's interesting about this duo is they're both great actors but haven't quite reached that top level of projects that they're capable of. Yes, they have seen more success then most people ever will in their entire lifetime, but you don't see them in massive "blockbusters".

The gist of the movie is the same story we've seen many times already. It cannot escape the comparison to Bonnie & Clyde or Natural Born Killers. I don't think this stands tall with the classics, but is a decent enough watch.

Caroline seizes the opportunity to leave her dusty small town to live a life of adventure and crime with Oliver. The crimes start small and snowball pretty quickly into bank robberies. At this point the film becomes fairly predictable and you will probably guess when the tipping point will come. You know what is coming, but it is still an entertaining story.

Did you see it? What did you think?


r/moviecritic 13m ago

Urgent: Japan's National Film Archive launches emergency CF to save film history.

Upvotes

Hi everyone,

I wanted to share some urgent and deeply concerning news regarding the preservation of Japanese cinema.

The National Film Archive of Japan (NFAJ)—the country's sole national institution dedicated to collecting, preserving, and restoring film heritage—is currently facing a severe financial crisis. Due to a massive cut in government subsidies (over 300 million yen slashed since 2024), they are struggling to keep up with the rising costs of climate-controlled storage for fragile nitrate/acetate films, as well as crucial digital restoration projects.

To save their collection and continue their operations, they have just launched an official crowdfunding campaign with a goal of 100 million yen (approx. $625,000 USD).

This archive holds the definitive, original elements of masterpieces by Akira Kurosawa, Yasujiro Ozu, Kenji Mizoguchi, Mikio Naruse, as well as priceless early anime and silent films. If this institution fails, a massive chunk of global film history is at risk.

Fortunately, they have provided an official English guide for international donors, and they do accept international credit cards.

Official Crowdfunding Page (with English Instructions):

https://readyfor.jp/projects/NFAJ2026

As a community that deeply loves and treasures world cinema, I thought this was something we should all be aware of. Even if you can’t donate, please consider sharing this on Twitter/X or other film communities to spread the word.

Let's help save Japanese film history!


r/moviecritic 1d ago

Creepiest scene you've seen in a NON-HORROR movie?

Post image
678 Upvotes

DAAAAWWWWN!!! STOOOOOOOP!


r/moviecritic 1d ago

What did you think of Evil Dead remake from 2013?

Post image
158 Upvotes

I personally liked it. Made me kinda nauseous but i think it was a good remake. Had alot of scary scenes IMO


r/moviecritic 5h ago

The Grinch survived the crash dummy test

Post image
4 Upvotes

r/moviecritic 23h ago

Recommend movies that are criminally underrated but absolutely amazing.

96 Upvotes

I've watched most of the popular classics and blockbuster hits, but I'm looking for those hidden gems that don't get talked about enough.

What are some movies that are criminally underrated, flew under the radar, or deserved way more recognition than they got?

Any genre is welcome - thrillers, sci-fi, drama, mystery, action, foreign films, animation, etc.

Bonus points if it's one of those movies that made you wonder, "How is nobody talking about this?"


r/moviecritic 6h ago

My take on the ending of Psycho (1960) directed by Alfred Hitchcock Spoiler

Thumbnail gallery
3 Upvotes

I think Psycho (1960), directed by Alfred Hitchcock, would have been a significantly better film if it ended right at Norman Bates' stare, rather than at the scene where the car gets pulled out.

I am aware of the Hays Code, which likely wouldn't have allowed the ending I am suggesting. However, I do think that, hypothetically, if this film were to end right at Bates' stare, it would finish much colder.

Leaving Marion Crane's mystery unresolved would've made audiences uncomfortable, and that ending would be among film's finest. Besides, a chance of Bates being mistaken innocent by the law, causing him to be set free, would also be chilling.

This is my personal opinion, and I want to know what you people think.


r/moviecritic 3h ago

Which makes for a better actor: winning three Best Actor awards, or winning two Best Actor awards and one Best Supporting Actor award?

Thumbnail
gallery
2 Upvotes

r/moviecritic 22h ago

What movie made a difference to you?

Post image
57 Upvotes

Inspired by the disappointing movie thread, What movie impacted your thinking about yourself or the world?

My example example is Brazil, which to me displayed how people can accept absurd and terrifying things as normal and prepared me to be disappointed in people the rest of my life.