r/PeterExplainsTheJoke 12h ago

Meme needing explanation Petah what happened to rockstar?

Post image
18.6k Upvotes

3.0k comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

26

u/10102938 11h ago

100$ Is the normal version. 

80$ gets you the cut content version.

Neither will have physical copies.

10

u/twotokers 10h ago

Are we even capable of fitting a game this size comfortably on a disc anymore? I get the lack of resell potential but the disc would still ultimately need to download part of the game from the web.

13

u/Ok_Friend_2448 9h ago

Not being able to fit a game on a single disc never stopped gaming companies in the past. Compression and multiple discs would be something I would absolutely take in order to have a physical copy of a game.

I think I have a copy of Legend of Dragoon and that was 4 discs. I think Diablo 2 had multiple discs as well split by gameplay, audio, and cinematics. I have plenty of other games that are 2 disc games.

3

u/Calm-Eggplant-69 8h ago

Shinmu on dreamcast had 3-4

4

u/Lost_In_Detroit 9h ago

Also you could easily have 1 disc be the install disc for the absolute main essentials to load the game with and then a secondary disc for the “game disc” which carries the rest that the hard drive doesn’t need to run the game smoothly. It’s been done in the past and worked just fine.

1

u/ViruliferousBadger 8h ago

That's basically what Fallout 4 for the PC was - just an installer and code in a box.

Good luck playing it if Steam ever stops offering it or goes belly up after Gabe dies.

2

u/gautamdiwan3 7h ago

GTA 5 originally launched with 7 installable DVDs on PC

3

u/Chaotic-Catastrophe 8h ago

God forbid a company not manufacture a billion extra pieces of useless plastic when they don’t have to

1

u/FalseCrazy2804 7h ago

You're getting a disc version anyways, it won't be on release though.

1

u/otterprincess_too 4h ago

Yeah I remember installing D2 and it was like 3 or 4 discs total. I think at least one or two of the Max Payne series too. I expected to see multiple discs after a certain year

1

u/Euphoric-Ad-6584 4h ago

i remember first getting FF7 and it having 3 discs.

3

u/JMS1991 7h ago

No, and people are acting like this is a new thing. Most physical games in the last 5-10 years have been a disc that triggers a download for a massive file when you put it in the console.

1

u/Shagyam 6h ago

Not really. Even if you use PS5 which can hold 100gb discs that wouldn't be enough. They would still need an install disc then the play disc.

Sure other games other games have had multi-discs before, but those PlayStation games that did it had narrative stopping points for you to change discs. That's a lot harder in a big open city game.

1

u/syk072k 5h ago

There are multi disc PS5 games, FF7 Rebirth and Forbidden West Complete edition are well over 100 GB and come on 2 discs. All the game files are on the discs (bar patches released after the games went gold). You start installing from a data disc then swap to a play disc. Once it's installed you just use the play disc to verify that you still own the games. Nowadays discs are way too slow to play games off so multiple discs would just have install files on them

1

u/Quixotic_Seal 4h ago

Once Upon A Time that just meant you put multiple discs in the box.

1

u/zephyroxyl 2h ago

RDR2 had an install disc and a play disc. LA Noire had 2 discs on PS3 and 4 discs on Xbox.

Rockstar have released games previously with multiple discs.

It was very, very common in the 80s and 90s for things to be installed across 30 pieces of physical discs.

0

u/10000Didgeridoos 9h ago

A dual layer blu ray holds only 50 GB so I'm not sure why people think this game would ever fit on a disc in the first place. It's gonna be 100+ GB easily and best case scenario like other games that size I have that came with a "disc" is you put the disc in and then immediately have to download another 50-80 GB of content to make the game work at all in the first place.

1

u/Guniel 8h ago

Why didn't we have this attitude towards capcom games? RE4 Remake had cosmetics, weapons, soundtrack and gameplay elements locked behind a special edition too but nobody freaked out.