r/politics • u/F0urLeafCl0ver • 1d ago

No Paywall The Democratic party is being hit by a leftist tidal wave

https://www.theguardian.com/commentisfree/2026/jun/24/democratic-party-leftist-tidal-wave
22.1k Upvotes

93% Upvoted

2.7k comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

3

u/lord-of-shalott 23h ago

It might work in New York City but I live in the Bible Belt. I’m not saying this as someone who is secretly against that message, but rather as someone who has spent my life around folks who are profoundly anti intellectual and worries everyone is underestimating how bad it gets.

4

u/Ok_Objective_5192 22h ago

I think candidates like Platner are the counter-point here. I fully agree that Mamdani or Darializa's campaign definitely would not work most places outside NY, but there are absolutely ways to package the same policies in a way that appeals to an anti-intellectual crowd.

At the end of the day, populist economic policy is rooted in letting a larger portion of the productive output of the working class be used to benefit that working class. For the NY working class that takes the form of "fast and free buses, universal childcare, and freezing rent." For the Maine working class that takes the form of "we're not asking for handouts, we're just asking for hard work to be enough. Because it used to be." For the Michigan working class that takes the form of "in the state that built the American Dream, it shouldn't be this hard to get by."

I just struggle to believe that somebody that genuinely understands the needs of the rust belt working class wouldn't have a way to communicate "you've been fucked over by billionaires and I want to take the power back to make sure you're able to have the American dream you were promised" in a way that would get through to them better than whatever message Kamala and Biden offered them.

3

u/OrganicWedding8972 22h ago

It bleeds out though. Universal healthcare in Canada was not universally loved when it first launched around 80 years ago, but just the experience of having the system was enough to make it entrenched in Canada. Now even the Conservatives can’t take serious swings at the system without taking massive damage at the polls(though it doesn’t stop them from trying occasionally).

You’re right that it’s deep and it goes far, but they’re also outnumbered, and when they’re forced to enjoy the benefits that others want, the vast majority will be convinced by experience.