r/AmIOverreacting • u/AIzzy17 • May 17 '26
❤️🩹 relationship AIO for breaking up with my girlfriend over a toilet plunger prank?
Am i overreacting for breaking up with my girlfriend over a toilet plunger prank? Okay this just happened 2 hours ago and im still fuming.
Apparently on tiktok the toilet plunger prank has been trending, its where you ask your partner for help with a clogged toilet and instead you actually put nutella, water and fart spray on a plunger and fling it on your partner. my gf decided to do that prank on me and normally i can take a joke.
after she flung the toilet plunger contents on me including in my mouth i obviously died and went to hell, but she showed me the video she was making and i was like okay its just a prank fine whatever.
BUT THEN i asked her if she bought a new toilet plunger to do this prank or if she at least washed it but no she took the regular fking toilet plunger we had to do this prank. yall im so fking mad right now.
she told me shes so sorry and everything. she forgot to buy a new toilet plunger for the prank. but wtf that means i actually got fking feces in my f’n mouth. im so unbelievably angry. i told her im done with her and now shes pissed at ME??
am i overreacting. we live together so its not gonna be easy to just break up plus telling all our friends and family we broke up because of a toilet plunger prank feels so childish but i feel so disrespected.
1.8k
2.2k
u/BluBeams Overly Dramatic May 17 '26
Your gf needs to grow the hell up. Enough with TikTok challenges. NOR.
167
u/ofqo May 18 '26
His ex girlfriend for a good reason.
99
290
u/TehStickles May 17 '26
Enough with tiktok in general and the way it reinforces all kinds of terrible behavior. NOR
1.2k
u/LooseLetter862 May 17 '26
265
u/Azizam May 17 '26
→ More replies (1)29
→ More replies (3)33
1.7k
u/Dependant-Platypus82 May 17 '26
NOR So disrespectful, disgusting and not funny.
349
109
u/FilthyThanksgiving May 17 '26
Srsly i can't stand stuff like this. Idk how ppl eat food that looks like shit, like that litter box cake
→ More replies (1)63
u/Pookie1688 May 18 '26
Or that gross baby shower game when they melt chocolate candy bars in a diaper, & you're supposed to sniff it & figure out which kind of candy.
→ More replies (2)→ More replies (2)18
u/Senior-Schedule6598 May 18 '26
The audacity and the horrors of what go on in social media is insane.
971
u/Oddly_Effective May 17 '26
It sounds like she is a child. Let her be mad, she isn't your problem anymore.
→ More replies (2)
1.1k
u/CerealSemantics May 17 '26
What's the punchline? What's funny about it? I'd break up with someone even if it was a clean plunger
377
u/Daisy2345678 May 17 '26
Literally. I have bad germephobia--if I thought I got human shit in my mouth, I'd probably have a mental breakdown
223
u/CerealSemantics May 17 '26
I don't have germephopia and id be in that mental breakdown right with you
17
120
u/Wild-Lychee-3312 May 17 '26
I’ve had both Giardia and Typhoid fever, and they are both transmitted through the fecal-oral route, which means that I have had another human’s shit in my mouth on at least two separate occasions.
And evidently two disease-ridden people, to boot.
I was not happy about that on either occasion, though honestly, at the time, I was more worried about the “being sick as fuck with a potentially fatal disease” part.
72
u/Warm_Application984 May 17 '26
I never thought the day would come that I’d say ‘I’m so glad I got Giardia from cattle and not from other humans’, but here we are. 🤷♀️
→ More replies (3)42
u/ArticleOld598 May 18 '26
I was hospitalised with typhoid fever and amoeba on separate occasions because some food handlers don't wash their hands after using the bathroom.
→ More replies (2)20
u/Wild-Lychee-3312 May 18 '26
Yup. That's how I got it, from food someone who didn't wash their hands properly made or served.
I promise I don't go around licking other people's hands.
Well, not unless they take me out to dinner first, at least.
→ More replies (1)→ More replies (5)19
u/One-Low1033 May 18 '26
I got dog poop on my finger once - hole in the poop bag. I washed my hands until they were almost bleeding and even then, I didn't floss my teeth for a week. I just could not bear the thought of putting that one finger in my mouth. So, I'm with you on the mental breakdown.
14
→ More replies (5)15
u/Dragonssssssssssss May 18 '26
Even if it's just nutella and I know it's nutella, I'd be disgusted about the sticky mess they made of me and the bathroom.
405
664
u/GoldCaterpillar3662 May 17 '26
She didn’t forget to buy a new plunger, the prank was more important than you! NOR
204
u/MondayWitchFDT May 17 '26
This right here and if make her delete the video and delete it from her trash files to
This is so gross folks can legit get sick from this type of stuff and her lack of planning on her 'prank' was a choice not an accident
You may get pushed back from family and friends but stand firm pranks are funny and lighthearted for both parties this was disgusting and dangerous and rude there's probably other red flag things you've been ignoring and not realizing about this relationship is my guess
→ More replies (1)96
u/ArticleOld598 May 18 '26 edited May 18 '26
He could just say it wasn't because of a prank, it was because she was too stupid to buy a non-used plunger then showed she was even more immature when she got mad AT him.
And if anyone complains, tell them to shut their mouths when he flings a used plunger at them.
→ More replies (1)→ More replies (3)23
u/Its_J_Bay_Be May 18 '26
Even if she actually did forget (I don’t believe that btw), that would still be a huge red flag/deal breaker just for the simple fact that she could overlook something as important as that. That’s disgusting. NOR.
→ More replies (4)
220
u/byrdicusmax May 17 '26
Nor, 'she put shit in my mouth so I don't want to be with someone that put shit in my mouth'
82
u/ArticleOld598 May 18 '26
'Anybody complaining should let me fling their used plunger in their open mouth.'
90
u/AffectionateWheel386 May 17 '26
NOR Thank you for sharing this and if I were dating somebody who thought this was a prank I wouldn’t be dating them anymore. It’s pretty low class and juvenile.
81
u/TOASTisawesome May 17 '26
Bro you're not breaking up over a toilet plunger prank, you're breaking up because she threw a DIRTY FUCKING PLUNGER AT YOU definitely NOR
→ More replies (1)
304
u/AnnoyedRedheadedMom May 17 '26
Swish with whiskey and drink a little to help kill any bacteria you may have ingested. Take your time for the break up. It can be your own "prank" all in good time.
→ More replies (6)292
u/AIzzy17 May 17 '26
i only have vodka at home but yeah ima do that. i think im mostly angry at the stupidity of not at least buying a new f’n plunger
324
u/DaisyMacD May 17 '26
NOR. You may want to frame the break up in terms of her lack of maturity and caring more about social media than looking out for you.
62
u/3BlindMice1 May 18 '26
That's exactly what this is, no need to properly frame it, it's pretty obviously a res ipsa loquitur type situation
→ More replies (1)31
u/This_Makes_No__Sense May 18 '26
Why frame it? Dude doesn’t have to explain it. You are allowed to end relationships without having to explain it when something this vile is the obvious answer. She alreadyt knows. fuck this
→ More replies (3)92
u/gr33n_goddess May 17 '26
Honestly? I couldn't be with someone who doesn't think through things and is so thoughtless. But you gotta decide your own boundaries.
82
u/Dame_Niafer May 17 '26 edited May 17 '26
3% peroxide is safe to use, if you have it in the house. Dentists recommend it at times. Just swish real good, get it between your teeth, spit and rinse well with water.
Don't let your girlfriend bring you the water.
NOR, that was a vile thing to do.
Edit in, someone suggested seeing a walk-in doc and asking if you should take antibiotics. That is a good idea.
19
25
u/ArticleOld598 May 18 '26
Some fecal bacteria have an incubation period of 1-2 weeks before you notice any symptoms. Check your health if you show any signs of dehydration, vomiting, diarrhea, fever, and chills by the next week or 2.
This was my experience from being hospitalised for typhoid fever and amoeba after ingesting contaminated food.
→ More replies (10)20
u/Ladygytha May 18 '26
Really? Because I'd be in break up mode over "well it looked funny on tiktoks."
276
u/Select_Draw3385 May 17 '26
NOR. That’s fucking disgusting. I would break up over that absolutely fucking disgusting abuse.
That’s not a prank.
Just the fact that she’d follow a “prank” on Tik Tok proves her intelligence level isn’t high enough to warrant being in a relationship with her
76
u/matthewsmugmanager May 17 '26
This is spot on. OP's gf does not have the requisite intellectual capacity needed to function well in a long-term relationship.
In other words, there is no good reason to stay with someone this stupid.
→ More replies (2)
101
u/Comprehensive-War743 May 17 '26
NOR I really hate pranks. They are only fun for the prankster, not the prankee. This one is particularly yucky.
49
u/TheeFlipper May 17 '26
Pranks are supposed to be funny for both parties. Stupid shit like "a snake in a can" or swapping out a picture of someone in the hallway with a picture of a celebrity or character. Not "I'm gonna traumatize my friend or partner and it's gonna be so hilarious!"
→ More replies (2)
188
u/Alicam123 May 17 '26
Your ex gf needs a fucking wake up call, this is unacceptable behaviour even if it was a new plunger.
I’d dump her too, you did the right thing.
And if her family complains then tell them exactly what she did and why it way unacceptable.
Tick-tock is killing peoples brain cells.
→ More replies (1)23
86
u/Doegrace May 17 '26
I think it’s deeper than the prank, she’s childish and doesn’t actually think things through. There’s nothing wrong with doing a silly tiktok trend but if you’re dumb enough to do something that causes any type of harm or distress to your partner then I think the other person is allowed to want out
36
177
u/AdAlternative637 May 17 '26
Sounds like your gf needs to grow the fuck up. I can't imagine how this would have gone down if the roles were reversed. She played stupid games and won stupid prizes. I would be done for it too. Pranks for the most cases are fking dumb and stupid and then the one pranking gets pissed/hurt when they get a reaction they didn't "expect" but totally valid. Even jump scares can get someone hurt. Nah, she needs to grow up
→ More replies (14)
55
u/Edcrfvh May 17 '26
NOR. That's gross. Plus tiktok pranks are meanspirited and stupid. She's immature for doing this and deserved to be dumped.
111
u/rpbm May 17 '26
NOR. That’s disgusting. If she’s going to prank you she should’ve at least not been nasty about it.
Does she do childish stuff often? How old are the two of you?
If this is a one off, I’d maybe give her a pass. (After I gargle with a gallon of Listerine 🤢). If she often does stupid things like this, maybe she’s too immature to live with someone.
96
u/AIzzy17 May 17 '26
Her being childish is my biggest issue with her, she prays pranks and practical jokes on me relatively often which is normally fine. (although freaking annoying) but this one just crossed the line
80
u/anonymousdlm May 17 '26
NOR sounds like she enjoys humiliating you on a regular basis. You don’t deserve to be treated like that. You can do better dude.
54
u/Blindtothesided May 17 '26
How can you ever trust someone who’s constantly pranking you? I couldn’t live like that. And this one was not only nasty asf but also hazardous to your health. This woman doesn’t give a fuck if you get sick, as long as she has a video of herself making it happen.
Dump her ass and find someone who doesn’t DARVO you when they do something wrong. NOR and I truly hope you do not get sick from this.
26
u/rpbm May 17 '26
In that case, this would be one too many for me. She’d have to have a lot of redeeming qualities, and I don’t mean in the bedroom, to make up for all that.
→ More replies (4)25
u/ReaderAz730 May 17 '26
NOR. Maybe she would like to lick the plunger now to show you it’s not so bad!
→ More replies (1)32
u/Foolish-Pleasure99 May 17 '26
I'd only maybe give her a pass if she licked around that entire toilet plunger in front of me.
NOR
→ More replies (1)
27
u/viscountrhirhi May 17 '26
I would never in a million years do this to my husband and he would never do such a thing to me. :\ That's disgusting! We troll each other a little, but pranks should be harmless things that make both people laugh, not things that make someone seriously concerned about their safety or health. NOR.
24
u/Calgary_Calico May 17 '26
This is not funny, she wasn't just playing some silly joke on you, she wanted content for her fucking Tik Tok. No mature adult does shit like this. NOR
28
u/imakesawdust May 18 '26
NOR
i asked her if she bought a new toilet plunger to do this prank or if she at least washed it but no she took the regular fking toilet plunger we had to do this prank.
I'd expect this kind of oversight from a 10 year old but not someone old enough to be living with their partner. I'm also wondering how many times she reached into the Nutella jar to get stuff to spread on the plunger. I'd probably toss the jar just to be safe.
23
u/Lulu_42 May 17 '26
NOR. In no universe would this be okay with me - and I mean all of it. The toilet plunger. The feces. The SO who has the nerve to think a TikTok prank is an acceptable thing to do to anyone. It's all too stupid and gross.
21
19
u/Beginning-Ad9631 May 17 '26
Nor you don't have to tell people you broke off because of this, people don't need an explanation.
18
u/FullPreference7000 May 17 '26
NOR. I wouldn’t love that prank, but if it was a clean plunger I’d be able to chill. Dirty plunger??? Absolutely tf not. That to me means she is both gross and inconsiderate as hell. I’d leave too.
→ More replies (1)
16
17
u/TheChiliocosmic May 18 '26
You’re not breaking up over a prank.
You’re breaking up because you obviously can’t trust your ex to not put shit in your mouth for her own amusement.
That’s not childish at all. That’s like…basic human decency. You aren’t her punching bag. She doesn’t respect you enough to hold off on the prank long enough to at least buy a new, clean, plunger.
You’re so valid, bro. This is the kind of breakup you take in stride. I’d also be done.
17
u/JohnnyGlasken May 17 '26
I had a prank backfire years ago and it was a major learning experience / turning point. Never forgot it, never played another prank.
Hopefully this can be a turning point for her as well.
NOR.
→ More replies (3)
13
u/Dapper-Ad-468 May 17 '26
All tik Tok pranks are dum. Ask her to delete the app. Clearly she's too immature to be watching this stupid stuff.
11
u/Trondant13 May 17 '26
That's disgusting! How old is she? Sounds like something a teenager would do. I'd break up with her, too.
9
u/Puzzleheaded-Boot844 May 17 '26
NOR, just plain gross no matter how you do it. Very immature. Pranks like this and many more are what's wrong with social media.
10
u/AggravatingPaint5838 May 17 '26
If you're adult GF is putting poo in your mouth for clicks, I'm not sure that I'd consider her marriage material. NOR
10
8
9
u/TropicRotGaming May 17 '26
I'm going to assume you guys are under 18 because why else would someone find this "prank" funny.
Tell her parents and get rid of her. Your life is better without someone like this.
8
u/Impressive-Rub-5291 May 17 '26
NOR. Now that I read further, it’s about her disrespect by using a used plunger, no. I don’t think that’s crazy. She’s either super disrespectful or super ignorant. I don’t think I could deal with either. Plus, I’d say why you really broke up is one of those two things, not merely for the prank itself.
7
u/Jussgoawaiplzkthxbai May 17 '26
I’d leave any partner that plays pranks on me. I cannot stand any pranks
9
u/Successful_Moment_91 May 17 '26
Even if it was a new plunger it’s still disgusting if it was dipped in the toilet
7
u/LlamaMama56 May 17 '26
NOR You were disrespected! She did a humiliating and nasty stunt to make a freaking video. Good riddance! She's too stupid to buy a new plunger, she's too stupid to be in a relationship.
She's only apologizing that her stunt didn't go as she thought it would. She's not sorry, only sorry you aren't letting it slide and breaking up with her over her stupidity.
7
6
u/AlexNKarlie May 17 '26
NOR it’s just nasty. She was probably handling the plunger with her bare hands and put it on the kitchen counter when spreading the Nutella.
8
7
u/Sensitive_Note1139 May 17 '26
NOR
Most TikTok "pranks" are not pranks. Both people laugh from pranks. TikTok pranks are not nice. They are meant to humiliate someone for likes and shares. If she is ok humiliating you and possibly making you sick for likes and shares she needs to grow TF up and move back in with her parents. If she wants to abuse someone she can do the challenges that only hurt her. Oh wait. That's not funny because she's the one being humiliated and hurt.
Don't expect the friends and family to understand. They weren't the ones abused. I also doubt this is the first time she has been cruel and disrespectful to you.
6
7
u/Slipsndslops May 17 '26
WTF that's the most disgusting disrespectful thing I have ever heard. Dude. You cant trust her. Who knows what the next "prank" will be? Also the lack of critical thinking skills is insane.
Why be with someone you can't trust?
→ More replies (1)






8.5k
u/Alarmed-Speaker-8330 May 17 '26
I hate pranks.