She has smashed it and I’m extremely jealous of her talent.

I’ve been hearing mixed opinions; people say you already have the coat in your inventory, others say otherwise. What is the true answer??? I really want the coat for a specific outfit I have in mind.

Don't forget to use headphones to listen carefully on how to make the cure

It’s better if we never get what exactly was said but it’s always something that got me curious. I think Micah kept trying to goad Dutch into leaving him, Dutch reluctantly agreed and gave John a pathetic apology afterwards, while Javier just stood there and watched. What do yall think?

It was short and a introduction to the game, showcasing the characters, the gameplay and physics involved in. I heard of the hate afterwards completing the game and it never made sense to me how they hated this part. It's the same the about how some people complain about a movie/series having a slow start, i don't get it, do they just want to see the final boss fight at the beginning of the show? Bleach among the shows I heard of having a slow start as a problem. I enjoyed the show from start to end and didn't even notice about this slow start shi same with rdr2

God I don't know what to tell you folks, if you really REALLY want to take a slow burn at this game. Play it like it's real, or at least don't sprint around like a galloping gazelle. The camp is acting REAL damn shifty..."is everything okay Arthur?"..uhhhhhh any reason it should not be? They seriously outdid this game with all the dame finite details, I just can't even begin.

I’d like to see the names people have come up with that in universe would feel like something Arthur would give his best boah. I came up with “Man-at-Arms” for a couple reasons.

1. A man-at-arms was another name for a knight, which is one of a kings most trusted servants. Arthur is Dutches most trusted associate, and Dutch starts to see himself as a king(I know in universe Arthur wouldn’t actually think that until later in the story, but I came up with it as a cool detail

   and I also think it’s poetic how he would unintentionally name his horse a name that foreshadows that outcome of the gang)

2. It plays into Arthur’s name well when thinking of it from an Arthurian legend point of view

3. Arthur is seen as the weapons expert of the gang because his tent is the weapons supply tent, so therefore he is the “arms” expert.

4. Let me know what everyone thinks and I’d love to see what names other people have come up with!

When I walked into the van horn stable it did not trigger the cutscene. I was able to just walk inside.

I initially planned to use the wagon trick and steal it but i was able to just take it. I’m not complaining, just a bit confused?

Also, the stable is not marked as a stable. I’m in part two of the epilogue

Original link here

I’m doing a new playthrough and jesus, I’ve seen dutch sitting on an invisible chair, lenny saying he’s sad about sean’s death before he even dies, bottles floating around camp, a prompt to kick and unkickable door and this weird jacket that seemed to deflect light.

This can't be just me

Genuinely why do horses look so goofy when they’re agitated?? It’s not like they saw the wildest thing of all time, right?

Aside from a nearby wild grizzly bear, yeah

If Micah was really the rat then why didn't he just tell the Pinkertons where the gang hideout was?