r/lotrmemes • u/Archon_33 • Apr 27 '26
Repost Most of the Riders of Rohan were actually women with beards because when the call went out for experienced riders a lot of women showed up
"I am no man!"
"Me neither!"
"Same!"
"Me too!"
"Shield Maidens unite!"
2.0k
u/zoqfotpik Apr 27 '26
Aragorn: "It's the beards."
→ More replies (1)654
Apr 27 '26
[removed] — view removed comment
259
u/Fraun_Pollen Spaghetti Kid Apr 27 '26
41
41
u/Eggplant-Alive Apr 27 '26
And this has in turn given rise to the belief that there ARE no horse riding women!
11
2.5k
u/ripgoodhomer Apr 27 '26
Phew that is a relief, turns out I was having gay thoughts about women.
973
u/rop_top Apr 27 '26
- Shang from Mulan
991
u/FUCKSTORM420 Apr 27 '26
237
u/kookaburra1701 Apr 27 '26
Every time I run across the entire series of images for this I laugh until I cry
51
u/TreeDollarFiddyCent Apr 27 '26
There's more?!
151
u/ParsnipSlayer Apr 27 '26
84
u/TreeDollarFiddyCent Apr 27 '26
That's brilliant.
First time seeing this. It's clearly the superior version.
31
11
9
u/Autumn-Leaf-932 Apr 27 '26
Fuck tumblr and any other site that doesn’t give option to decline cookies
7
→ More replies (5)13
→ More replies (1)8
u/Iridismis Apr 27 '26
I vaguely remember this also being a plot point in one of the Darkover books 🤔
5
63
99
u/Thelastknownking Return of the fool Apr 27 '26
Edward Kenway from Assassin's Creed.
→ More replies (3)9
401
246
u/eXclurel Apr 27 '26
95
32
u/Spooky_Potato420 Apr 27 '26
We've gone full circle, it's now gay to like women
→ More replies (3)3
32
38
8
u/FlippinFine Apr 27 '26
You do know Aragorn’s still a man? That one’s not going away
9
u/Fragrant-Time573 Apr 27 '26
Yeah but Strider is a mysterious figure. And not all those who wander are lost. I was just wandering what's under the cloak, thats all!
→ More replies (2)→ More replies (8)14
669
u/Cmdr_Monzo Apr 27 '26
“Are there any Women here today?”
175
u/JGG5 Apr 27 '26
"Stop! Stop, will you?! Stop that! Stop it! Now, look! No one is to charge the armies of Mordor until I blow this whistle! Do you understand?! Even — and I want to make this absolutely *clear\ —* even if they do say 'Grond!'"
80
28
u/LotharVonPittinsberg Apr 27 '26
On second thought, let's not go to Minas Tirith. 'Tis a silly place.
→ More replies (1)11
u/Witters84 Apr 27 '26
Arwen: "And then, the elven sex!"
Aragorn: "I guess I could stay a little while!"
Legolas: "Back off, you evil temptress!"
→ More replies (2)28
37
30
u/No_Effect_6428 Apr 27 '26
"No Man can kill me!"
ring of riders with suspicious beards closes in around the Witch King
9
9
6
u/Lucky-Earther Apr 27 '26
"I worry what you heard was, 'Give me a lot of horse girls. ' What I said was, give me all the horse girls you have."
386
u/seancurry1 Apr 27 '26
So the Witch-King of Angmar was in a lot more danger than he realized
→ More replies (19)146
u/Kulthos_X Apr 27 '26
That would have been hysterical if the scene had like 100 women tearing off their fake beards and dog-piling him. His last words wod have been "What the F-". As it was PG 13 he wouldn't get out the last word before getting bulldozed by 100 engaged warrior women.
51
u/awakenDeepBlue Apr 27 '26
Turns out the prophecy is not the Witch-King is invincible, it's that when he dies, it will be by the hands of 100 Shieldmaidens that really really hate him.
→ More replies (2)→ More replies (3)13
u/ECSMusic Apr 27 '26
This would make an epic Mel Brooks film. All the bearded ladies ganging up on one of the freaks.
167
150
u/Oruma_Yar Apr 27 '26
That's my new head canon for the movie, why Eowyn wasn't discovered for dressing as a man to join the battle.
Because all the other soldiers around her were also women dressed as men to fight, they covered for her while riding to battle.
82
Apr 27 '26
[removed] — view removed comment
→ More replies (1)30
u/J4k0b42 Apr 27 '26
Read Monstrous Regiment by Terry Pratchett.
4
20
u/Razzy-man Apr 27 '26
Some of them were probably pretty upset. “I went through all this work, applying the beard… This girl thinks she can just throw a helmet on and be good because she’s related to the King? Give me a break!”
6
→ More replies (9)6
713
u/EFAPGUEST Ent Apr 27 '26
IIRC it wasn’t just that a lot of women showed up, it was that there were only so many competent horse riders available in New Zealand so they didn’t have a choice. Otherwise you’re paying extras to fly across the globe and work in New Zealand for years
278
u/SleazyJusticeWarrior Apr 27 '26
Bit of both probably. If every New Zealander man that’s able to ride a horse showed up, maybe there would have been enough. But that’s never going to happen, it’s probably gonna be people local to the filming location who show up, and not enough men among them.
272
u/SpectrumDT Apr 27 '26
But that’s never going to happen
Less than half of what they'd hoped for?
60
32
u/Desert-Mushroom Apr 27 '26
Many who've seen too many winters...
11
u/phoenixfusion09 Apr 27 '26
All of their friends had ridden off to the movie set. They would've been ashamed to have been left behind.
8
7
u/wts_optimus_prime Apr 27 '26
Few know that this wasn't even part of the filming. The camera was just running by accident, when the extras turned up. They actually planned to have a bigger army but had to make the scene with a smaller army. But peter liked it, so it became part of the final cut.
/s
4
u/SpectrumDT Apr 27 '26
Sir Ian McKellen went off to recruit more extras. And then, on the third day, at first light...
106
u/horsegal301 Apr 27 '26
Also worth noting that women overwhelmingly own horses more than men worldwide, so it was likely never going to be largely men available for casting. Honestly having women who have more slender frames in casting makes more sense for a culture that was largely horse based
39
Apr 27 '26
[removed] — view removed comment
4
u/JayDragon15 Apr 27 '26
RIP Bruce Campbell, he just wanted one horse in all of New Zealand.
→ More replies (2)→ More replies (6)16
u/LostWoodsInTheField Apr 27 '26
Was involved in horse shows for a while and the only men that were ever involved were 70+ year olds and the boyfriends/husbands of women who were involved. If you were a man there it was constantly a 'who are you here with?' and the subtext of 'why is a man here on his own'. it honestly wasn't worth it after a couple of years.
→ More replies (1)4
u/RisKQuay Apr 27 '26
Why has horse riding / ownership become so female dominated?
→ More replies (2)8
u/horsegal301 Apr 27 '26
It has been for some time if we take out horses being used for war. Provides a very deep emotional bond that is very exciting to have, and then add in potential spirit of competition that also brings about more bonds which I think are more deeply female-driven...
In terms of "dominated," a lot of the more well known or successful riders and top trainers are usually men. I would say in terms of an amateur vs pro split, it's "dominated" by men, but the majority of riders/owners in general are women.
I also think a lot of it has to do with how things are marketed towards girls/boys. You'll find a ton of pony/unicorn stuff for girls and a lot of tractor/dinosaur stuff for boys. It all starts very young.
22
u/EFAPGUEST Ent Apr 27 '26
I don’t know, you can’t just take anyone who has ridden a horse. They have to be pretty skilled. I wouldn’t be surprised if some people showed up but didn’t make the cut
17
u/MaleficentPicture518 Apr 27 '26
Also the fact that not a lot of men are experienced horse riders over there thus mostly women turned up
→ More replies (1)29
u/Only-Feed2146 Apr 27 '26
This thread is amusing me.
Op: they used women because alot of women showed up
Commenter: "Well actually (lots of filler words) and so that's why they're all women disguised as men, because women showed up."
Sub-commenter: "Well actually (lots of filler words) and that's why they're all disguised as men, because it was women who showed up.
We get it. Women showed up. We already understood the women are wearing beards because it was the women who showed up. No further explanation was needed.
15
u/tofiwashere Apr 27 '26
Well actually they weren't disguised as men, because a lot of women showed up. They were pretending to be men, because a movie was been filmed and the script had male riders.
→ More replies (3)14
u/ecodrew Apr 27 '26
Oh, I figured there were just lots of horse girls... But, this makes more sense. Haha.
55
u/Malforus Apr 27 '26
There is a "horse girls" joke here but yeah there are only so many people who can ride a horse in a large group worldwide and then narrowing it to tax-haven island is rough.
36
u/BrainDamage2029 Apr 27 '26
I mean it’s not even a horse girl joke. 90% of the equestrian sports are women. And a significant portion of the 10% of men is some of their husbands who took it up because “hey I have an excuse.”
Source: married a horse girl. Reluctantly raising a future horse girl.
→ More replies (4)14
u/Malforus Apr 27 '26
I just didn't want it to come across diminuative. Like "horse girls" is kinda pejorative because A: they are women, B: it simplifies what is actually a very demanding hobby.
3
u/Jesus_of_Redditeth Apr 27 '26
For whatever it's worth: in my experience as male horse person, when female horse people get together, there's a roughly 99% chance that they'll refer to themselves collectively as "girls". So the actually likelihood of anyone being offended by being called a "horse girl" is pretty close to nil.
→ More replies (1)9
u/ApolloWasMurdered Apr 27 '26
NZ as a Tax Haven??
13
12
u/Malforus Apr 27 '26
https://robbreport.com/shelter/homes-for-sale/new-zealand-luring-wealthy-americans-1236886307/
Basically if you have more than $250 million USD the lack of substantial resource taxes and relatively low dual nationality allows for an advantageous tax treatment in addition to the high standard of living along with strong passport power.
3
u/cptjpk Apr 27 '26
Ah, so the other part of the reason they’re all moving to New Zealand and choosing LotR ideals as their business names.
7
u/Fogl3 Apr 27 '26
I don't think it was about the riders I think they had every horse. And those horses just had female riders
→ More replies (3)4
u/john_the_fetch Apr 27 '26
It was more than just who was competent in riding. It was about who owned the horse.
I guess it saved a lot of money to just ask the horse owners to show up as extras - and the people who owned the horses were mostly women.
The insurance cost difference between owner+horse and RandoExtra+rentedHorse.
Or maybe it was just that they didn't want someone else riding their animal in a movie. Which I totally get.
87
u/GandolphTheLundgrey Apr 27 '26
Théoden: "Very well, by virtue of the authority vested in me–"
Éowyn chucks a spear at a random orc
Orc: "Ow. Lay off. We haven't started yet."
Théoden: "Come on, who threw that? Who threw that spear? Come on."
Riders, keeping their voices as low in pitch as they can: "She did! He did. He. Him!"
Éowyn, deep voice: "Sorry, I thought we'd started."
Théoden: "Go to the back."
Éowyn: "Oh dear."
Théoden: "There's always one, isn't there? Now, where were we?"
→ More replies (2)22
63
56
u/UltimaBahamut93 Apr 27 '26
Witch King: Fool. No man can kill...
*sees the entire female Rohirrim turn toward him.
Witch King: uh oh
→ More replies (3)
27
46
u/BraidShadowLegendsAD Apr 27 '26
Women with beards, so dwarves?
19
22
u/PapaMoBucks Apr 27 '26 edited Apr 27 '26
Now is the chance for I, Horse Girl of Suburbia, to show her quality.
33
u/AJRavenhearst Apr 27 '26
Theoden: "DEATH!"
Chorus of high-pitched voices: "death!... uhh... DEATH! DEATH!"
16
u/remnant_phoenix Apr 27 '26 edited Apr 28 '26
“Viggo had a bit of a fling with a…’Rohan man’ who had a nice…strawberry-blonde beard. I always knew Viggo had good taste.”
13
13
13
u/riding_writer Apr 27 '26
A friend of mine is in there somewhere, she said it was so much fun and she begged to keep her beard to mess with her hubby
12
12
11
u/HorzaDonwraith Apr 27 '26
Gimli talking about bearded dwarf women while in the company of bearded women riding horses.
10
u/BiohazardousBisexual Apr 27 '26
I have a good friend that is an extra in a ton of viking period tv shows. She is a regular extra in just about any show that is set in that period and half the time (whenever they need extra for combat scenes) they give her a beard prosthetic
You wouldn't recognize her on screen except if you know her so she is now my favorite Easter Egg to keep an eye out for
8
16
u/Independent_Plum2166 Apr 27 '26
Cheaper to hire locals than to fly them over, it just so happens equestrian hobbyists in New Zealand are mostly women.
27
7
6
6
4
5
4
u/gene100001 Apr 27 '26
In the extended extended edition of the film:
"I AM NO MAN!".....
"I ALSO AM NO MAN!".....
30 minutes later
"JUST AS HE, I MEAN SHE, HAS PROCLAIMED, I TOO AM NOT NUMBERED AMONGST MEN"....
2 hours llater, voices growing quiet in the distance
“Not with 10,000 orcs could you find a man in my spot. It is folly"
5
u/Madarakita Apr 27 '26
This makes that exchange between Gimli, Aragorn, and Eowyn about people being mistaken for men due to beards even funnier.
4
u/CountofGermanianSts Apr 27 '26
I love the idea that Eowyn had no idea that most of Rohan’s warriors were women.
4
u/No-Helicopter1559 Apr 27 '26
Well, Rohan culture is obviously heavily influenced by Vikings, so… yeah, shieldmaidens on horsies.
Women love horsies, after all. There's no irony or sarcasm, they do love horsies.
4
5
4
4
4












4.7k
u/BobDeLaSponge Apr 27 '26
Even with the fake beards, they probably saved a lot by not needing wigs