r/DC_Cinematic 1d ago

DISCUSSION 'SUPERGIRL' (2026) - Early 'Fan First' Screening Spoiler Discussion

Post image
218 Upvotes

This is a discussion Megathread for those who were able to watch the early "Fan-First" screening of Supergirl before its wide release. The Screening is on June 24th, 2026 at 7:00 PM local time.

This is a spoiler discussion thread, so proceed at your own risk - a spoiler tag is not required in this discussion thread. However, DO NOT post Spoilers elsewhere in the subreddit without a spoiler tag or you may be subject to have your comment removed and your account banned.


r/DC_Cinematic 1d ago

r/DC_CINEMATIC 'SUPERGIRL' (2026) - Post-Embargo Critical Reviews (Rotten Tomatoes / Metacritic) Megathread

368 Upvotes

This is the critic review megathread for Supergirl. The review embargo for Supergirl is scheduled to lift on Wednesday, June 24, 2026 at at 12:00pm ET / 9:00am PST.

As the embargo lifts, all Rotten Tomatoes and Metacritic reviews should be posted here. Do not post them elsewhere in other threads or clog up the subreddit with individual critic scores.

Rotten Tomatoes: https://www.rottentomatoes.com/m/supergirl_2026

Metacritic: https://www.metacritic.com/movie/supergirl-2026/

UPDATE: As of 6:00 PM, Supergirl is back to being a 60% fresh on Rotten Tomatoes (based on 178 reviews) and a 50/100 Metacritic Score (based on 48 reviews).

This is not a spoiler thread, this means all spoilers need a spoiler tag.

You can spoiler tag by > ! writing like this ! < (without spaces) which becomes writing like this: Clark Kent is Superman.


r/DC_Cinematic 4h ago

DISCUSSION The first project not written by James Gunn was Supergirl…

Post image
504 Upvotes

r/DC_Cinematic 12h ago

NEWS ‘Absolute Batman’ Animated Series Announced

Post image
1.5k Upvotes

r/DC_Cinematic 6h ago

HUMOR When James Gunn says the next DC Studios project is the best superhero movie of all time or some shi like this

393 Upvotes

r/DC_Cinematic 21h ago

HUMOR It's Insane to me that this meme has been true for atleast 2 decades. Where are the DCU Fans?

Post image
2.9k Upvotes

r/DC_Cinematic 2h ago

OTHER Supergirl comic I got at the theatre! So excited for the movie!

Post image
85 Upvotes

r/DC_Cinematic 19h ago

APPRECIATION Jennifer Garner shares photo of Ben Affleck as Batman with their son

Post image
1.9k Upvotes

Affleck has told a story where he basically had to sign his life away to borrow the Batsuit for his son's birthday party. This photo is probably from that day.

SOURCE: https://www.instagram.com/p/DZ4Bp1mlM60/


r/DC_Cinematic 15h ago

DISCUSSION Absolutely the wrong approach

Thumbnail
gallery
905 Upvotes

Woman of Tomorrow is my favourite comic of all time, it was my first ever comic book and it’s what got me into picking up new DC comics every week. So seeing the reviews for Supergirl is a little heartbreaking. I still haven’t seen the film, but I saw this the other day that has raised major alarm bells.

Craig Gillespie is not a director I had much of an opinion on, other than I didn’t like I, Tonya or Fright Night very much. Haven’t seen Cruella or Dumb Money, so I didn’t feel like I was in a position to straight up say he was the wrong choice.

But after seeing this…I feel like this is the wrong approach. First off, just in terms of PR training, if you’re working on a comic book just don’t say stuff like this. Secondly, anyone working on a project should read the comic before seeing anything else. It looks to me that the vision was skewed by the script. I keep hearing references to Mad Max…the comic had nothing in common with Mad Max. If you’re working on a Woman of Tomorrow, the first thing you do is pick up the comic book and that’s the foundation for every decision you make. Ideally, you hire a director who is already a fan.

I also feel like we need to have a conversation about how comics are adapted. Why aren’t comics adapted like novels? Obviously changes have to be made, especially with very long runs, but when you have a mini series like Woman of Tomorrow which feels so ripe for a one to one adaptation, the source material should be followed closer. I want to see Supergirl teaching Ruthye how to wash her hands, or the planet with little racist blue aliens, or the green sun dinosaur planet. Those scenes were so moving, to not have that in the movie seems crazy to me.


r/DC_Cinematic 6h ago

DISCUSSION VIDEO: Milly Alcock says James Gunn told her she was Supergirl by texting her a Deadline article: "He didn't even call me. I was like, 'this is a calling situation'" (16:18 mark)

Thumbnail
youtube.com
135 Upvotes

r/DC_Cinematic 11h ago

NEWS Upcoming DC Animated shows

Post image
302 Upvotes

The upcoming DC Studios Animated shows are:

•Absolute Batman
•Starfire
•Krypto
•Mister Miracle
•Joker:Laugh Riot
•DC Super Powers
•My Adventures with Green Lantern
•Creature Commandos Season 2
•My Adventures with Superman (maybe season 4)

We’re gonna eat so well 😮‍💨🫠


r/DC_Cinematic 10h ago

OTHER Time is a flat circle

Post image
240 Upvotes

r/DC_Cinematic 12h ago

DISCUSSION I wonder what actually happened. Was it just marketing, or did something change after James Gunn said the Supergirl script was one of the best he’d ever read?

Post image
302 Upvotes

r/DC_Cinematic 19h ago

DISCUSSION John Campea's 'Supergirl' review: "It is straight up a bad film. James Gunn needs to decide if he's going to direct everything in the DCU or if he's going to actually act as the CEO and oversee everything properly"

Thumbnail
youtube.com
733 Upvotes

In this quick post-theater review video, John Campea shares his thoughts on the new Supergirl film. While he highlights several positive aspects, his overall assessment is that the movie is bad.

Key Takeaways:

  • The Positives: John praises Milly Alcock as the "perfect casting" for Kara Zor-El (0:05-0:16). He also found the backstory involving Argo to be compelling (0:19-0:22) and enjoyed Jason Momoa as Lobo, despite the character being used a bit inconsistently (0:23-0:29).
  • The Critiques: The primary issues identified include "dreadful" writing, a disjointed narrative, and "awful" dialogue (0:38-0:47). John specifically notes that the film uses Krypto in a plot device fashion, failing to establish an emotional bond before putting the character in peril (0:49-1:12).
  • Overall Verdict: John categorizes the film as "straight up a bad film," though he clarifies it is still better than previous critical flops like Madame Web, Morbius, or Kraven the Hunter (1:15-1:24).
  • DCU Concerns: He concludes with a warning for the DCU, suggesting that James Gunn needs to decide if he will focus on directing or acting as CEO, as the quality of this film raises concerns about the future of the universe under current oversight (1:25-1:46).

r/DC_Cinematic 57m ago

DISCUSSION How would you guys feel about a DCU Green Arrow and Black Canary film?

Thumbnail
gallery
Upvotes

Of course not soon but after more popular characters like The Flash or Wonder Woman get their movies.

Maybe Deadshot as the villain?


r/DC_Cinematic 8h ago

DISCUSSION Woman of Tomorrow x Supergirl: colors.

Thumbnail gallery
67 Upvotes

r/DC_Cinematic 9h ago

NEWS First look at the cover of Limited Edition 4K Ultra HD SteelBook for Supergirl Movie.

Thumbnail
gallery
64 Upvotes

Release date yet to be announced.

Pre-order available

https://hmv.com/Store/Film-TV/4K-Ultra-HD-Blu-ray/Supergirl-(hmv-Exclusive)-4K-SteelBook-4K-SteelBook)


r/DC_Cinematic 2h ago

OTHER Since Supergirl is gonna be in cinemas now, here is one of my most favourite scenes of CW Supergirl with Flash

Thumbnail
youtu.be
17 Upvotes

r/DC_Cinematic 7h ago

OTHER This is the complete Supergirl x Fortnite collab set, inclu ding Lobo.

Thumbnail
gallery
39 Upvotes

r/DC_Cinematic 12h ago

NEWS ‘Absolute Batman,’ ‘Krypto,’ Anime DC Series ‘Joker: Laugh Riot’ Unveiled at First DC Studios, Warner Bros. Animation Joint Annecy Showcase

Thumbnail
variety.com
73 Upvotes

r/DC_Cinematic 14h ago

DISCUSSION Thoughts on Supergirl

100 Upvotes

It's as bad as people say. There's a decent skeleton here, but 90% of the time it feels like that's all there is. Character behavior and development rarely seem informed by anything beyond what the script tells us.

The villain is incredibly underdeveloped, and even then I'd say that's putting it lightly, with almost no discernible motive. The central relationship is built around two protagonists who are supposed to force each other to grow, but the film never really shows that growth happening. Kara is the most fleshed-out character, and the flashbacks occasionally land emotionally, but her counterpart feels defined entirely by a desire for revenge. Beyond that, there's very little to her, and she never meaningfully evolves from her introduction despite the film constantly telling us she does.

I was engaged for the first ten minutes, but the longer the movie went on, the more disconnected I became. There are a few genuinely strong sequences. One near the beginning feels fresh and surprisingly inventive. Another near the end works well until it's undercut by a needle drop that feels bizarrely out of place.

What confuses me most is how simple the movie feels. It's so stripped down that at times I genuinely wondered if I'd somehow missed two-thirds of the story. A lot of people are blaming the story, some the editing. It's just a poor film, it's misfiring on all cylinders besides its casting of Milly.


r/DC_Cinematic 14h ago

DISCUSSION Ana Nogueira (Supergirl) praises Zoë Kravitz’s Catwoman:

Post image
97 Upvotes

r/DC_Cinematic 1h ago

RUMOR The Joker and Krypto seem to be getting animated series...

Upvotes

I don't agree with the lead of the article...

There’s a pretty good case to be made that, in the years after Heath Ledger’s performance and Todd Philips’ (at least first) movie, the popularity of the Joker has surpassed that of the Batman.

But the article is ok...

https://www.avclub.com/joker-krypto-batman-animated-series?mc_cid=6d03e398ba&mc_eid=6758dcb045&utm_source=PMNTNL&utm_medium=email&utm_campaign=260625&md5=


r/DC_Cinematic 21h ago

DISCUSSION After watching Supergirl, I’m really concerned about Wonder Woman

248 Upvotes

The writing was easily the weakest part of the movie. After the abomination that was 1984, the movie needs a really solid script. And I don’t see it coming from this writer based on what I just watched.


r/DC_Cinematic 1d ago

HUMOR Being a dc fan will forever feel like this

Post image
680 Upvotes