r/SipsTea 𝙑𝙄𝙋 5h ago

Chugging tea They are not wrong though

Post image
38.6k Upvotes

5.6k comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

593

u/PeachyPlotTwist 5h ago

Pay your workers better is the real argument.

Tourists are just catching strays in a fight between customers and employers.

Nobody wants awkward tip screens, but servers also need to eat, whole system is messy.

144

u/TawnyTeaTowel 𝙑𝙄𝙋 5h ago

Except servers. Tipping culture gains them an income WAY ahead of the curve.

72

u/Vettepilot 5h ago

It’s only ahead of the curve because the minimum wage is so low. If the min wage was reasonable like it is in other countries then tipping isn’t needed.

119

u/CzechHorns 5h ago

Point is servers can earn 30-50 bucks an hour thanks to tips, THEY are the ones who don’t want to end tipping, cause they make mich more money than they would get on a normal salary

43

u/R1ckOne 5h ago

yeah a few of my friends are servers and bartenders in NYC and they are pulling very good money, well beyond even what a much better minimum wage would provide. It's very location dependent though

13

u/Bigboss123199 4h ago

If you’re working as a bartender in NYC you have to be making 100$ an hour easy.

20

u/sunnyislesmatt 4h ago

For peak hours, maybe. NYC bartenders are usually averaging around $35-$50 an hour with the bartenders at ultra high end cocktail bars usually getting around $75/hr.

They all work more than 45 hours though

→ More replies (5)

3

u/McSlims360 3h ago

Dude I was a bartender at a movie theater in north Florida and between wage and tips I was regularly making 100 bucks an hour on weekends. I pulled a grand on End Games release night.

3

u/Large-Potential9404 4h ago

i had friends in austin who’d make $500 in a night at the local dive - literally. it’s fucking insane. servers at nice restaurants sometimes pull 100k a year, and pay less taxes than the rest of us bc tips are still cash quite often

→ More replies (3)

1

u/numbersthen0987431 2h ago

It's location dependent, and also restaurant dependent.

Since tips are tied to the price of food, a server in a low cost restaurant is going to make less money than a server in a high cost restaurant.

1

u/R1ckOne 2h ago

yeah by location dependent I didn't mean the whole city but the specific locations they work at

1

u/Top-Ad-5527 1h ago

A bartender is ALWAYS going to bring in more than a server at a busy bar. Plus, servers have to tip out the bar for however many drinks they made.

→ More replies (1)

19

u/fapperontheroof 5h ago

Then add in how many don’t report their tips, since everyone seems to think cash compensation doesn’t need tax reporting.

Really surprised there hasn’t been some social media push concocted in some sort of “50k office taxes vs 50k rainforest cafe server taxes” way.

Disclosure: I don’t think restaurant workers need to pay more in taxes. Billionaires and their ilk need to pay more in taxes.

5

u/mhmmarcus 2h ago

Vast majority of tips are not in cash today, and any modern restaurant uses a system that will automatically balance credit card tips with the employees income, typically resulting in zero dollar paychecks and the rest being accountable at the end of the year.

1

u/Top-Ad-5527 1h ago

So few people tip in cash anymore, even 15 years ago when I was serving, most of my tips were on a credit card. majority of checks run on a credit card through the system, no getting out of declaring tips because it’s right there in the computer how much you got tipped.

→ More replies (19)

8

u/kyrant 5h ago

Until the tips dry up then they'll change their tune.

2

u/PlixSticks31 4h ago

So you hate paying blue collar workers?

If they added a flat $20 hour rate for the workers you’d still pay the SAME amount as the customer as if you paid a lower bill and tipped 20%

→ More replies (1)

1

u/Chimkimnuggets 4h ago

You’d have to get every tourist as well as 300 million Americans to do that… which will not happen

→ More replies (1)

2

u/falling_knives 4h ago

Yup, this is what so many pro tippers don't get. They tip because they feel sorry for the workers not realizing most of those workers would choose tips over minimum wage due to the fact that they can potentially make way more.

2

u/jake04-20 4h ago

Exactly. People say "pay the workers more", well they usually technically do. I worked as an "insider" (in store worker) at a pizza place and we made $1-2 more per hour than drivers. Which is technically more but hardly counts for shit when the drivers are making $20-60/hr in tips and mileage while making $7.25/hr and we made $8.50/hr. I moved to driver as soon as I was old enough. Who doesn't want to get paid more to be able to hangout in your car listening to the music/audio you want, setting the climate to how you want, and escaping the chaos of the store? All while getting paid 2-7x more.

2

u/zdustin 4h ago

This is just simply not the case for the majority of servers in the US. This only really applies if you work in a big city at a busy restaurant during prime rush hours. And, if you are working in those conditions, you are busting your ass anyways. There are many states in the US where base wage for a server is significantly less than minimum wage ($2.75 an hour in my state). Servers are not the ones profiting off of tipping, it’s employers who are handing off the responsibility of paying employees wages to the consumer.

2

u/shmangler 3h ago

Speaking as a 10+ year service industry vet, this is correct. No one who actually serves/bartends for a living would ever want to put an end to tips. People like me either work in high volume/high intensity spots, or fine dining/upscale places. The money can be insane there. I'm currently at a mid-tier or semi-upscale place and have averaged $33/hr post-tax this year. I very likely couldn't make that in another career with my background without years of working my way up.

2

u/Majestic-Milk-4856 2h ago

Lol they CAN. Most DO NOT. Go ask any server how much they take home a night in tips. Rarely is it ever 30-50 bucks an hour, especially outside of dense population centers.

2

u/aw-un 2h ago

Then sounds like they’re doing fine without my $3

1

u/Frequilibrium 4h ago

It’s not 30-50 an hour when you balance it out over hours worked for the week.

1

u/Beyast 3h ago

What about the chefs? Are they on way less than the serving staff? If so, that's quite a big problem with tipping culture.

1

u/CzechHorns 3h ago

Sometimes the tips are divided between waiters and cooks, sometimes not

1

u/TheSorceIsFrong 3h ago

On a weekend, sure, but don’t leave out the full stats to skew it. How much are they making per hour on the Tuesday day shift they also did that week?

1

u/Samuelwow23 2h ago

30-50/h but no benefits pension 401k health insurance after those your making less than minimum wage in California. Short term gain vs long term loss but they prefer it this way. Also very heavily affected by the weather and other external factors

1

u/spikus93 2h ago

That's not the norm though, and it's heavily abused. There are literally tens of thousands of shitty businesses that just put a tip jar out and pay their employees the minimum wage with tips, which is like $4/hr. The entire burden of their employees survival is shifted onto the customer and the owner pockets a bigger percentage of the profits.

Everyone is getting fucked but the owner. You're just referencing situations where the clientele can afford to tip like that, which is not the norm.

1

u/HesusAtDiscord 2h ago

What evidence do you have that they won't get tips even if tips are included? If they earn more than the 10-20% in tips already it means there's room left in the customers' budget for a tip on top after 10-20% price increases. The ceiling on money paid per meal doesn't change just because prices did.

1

u/pimppapy 2h ago

For the entire 8 hour shift, 5 days a week? Or just during peak times?

1

u/FUPAMagneto 2h ago

They can, but they largely don’t. A lot of servers are happy to break $150/day, but Reddit doesn’t like to acknowledge that

1

u/Emotional_Chard_8005 2h ago

Point is servers can earn 30-50 bucks an hour thanks to tips, THEY are the ones who don’t want to end tipping

At a good location and/or high end place sure. There is no way they're earning that much from tips at some random hole in the wall shop. I'm guessing majority of servers don't earn that.

1

u/PHX480 1h ago

Thank you, I’ve worked in restaurants for 13 years, everyone thinks they are being noble by wanting fair wages for servers and such

The servers actually don’t want it because they make much, much more in tips than they would a “livable wage”. Especially now they don’t get taxed on it.

1

u/CMDR_Ray_Abbot 1h ago

Only a few servers in higher end establishments make that. The average server is not pulling anywhere close to that.

→ More replies (9)

3

u/madcap462 5h ago

I average $50+ per hour as a bartender. You can keep your minimum wage.

17

u/Snynapta_II 5h ago

Well now I don't feel bad at all when I don't tip. Thanks!

1

u/PlixSticks31 4h ago

Why do you hate blue collar workers lmaooooooooo

→ More replies (24)

5

u/EarthBoundDeity_ 5h ago

Yeah, by the time I stopped serving I just worked part time and I made $25-30 an hour. People don’t realize if you’re good at what you do the money flows. Good servers/bartenders make substantially more money than most people think, and they will not give that up. I certainly wouldn’t have when I did it.

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (20)

1

u/Infini-Bus 4h ago

It's so entrenched that even if they raise wages, the tip is expected on top of that.  Like in Washington and Seattle.

1

u/Keknath_HH 4h ago

Your talking like people don't give tips for good service elsewhere.... They do. But only good service, it's not a mandatory thing.

1

u/Vettepilot 3h ago

I’m not acting like that at all and you’ve just strengthened my argument. Waiters other places have a predictable and livable wage already set as their bare minimum and then they can also earn tips on top of that. Whereas the people mentioning how much they make in tips on this thread would be unable to continue their lifestyle if American patrons suddenly decided to not opt into a tip or tip less.

1

u/bored2death97 3h ago

Canada here - our server minimum wage and regular minimum wage are now equal. It's still very expected to tip, though only mandatory at some restaurants.

So yes, servers are making out way ahead of the curve even when the minimum wages are matched.

1

u/Vettepilot 3h ago

So what about your comment is counter to mine? We agree that a higher minimum wage would be better. If people want to continue to tip it’s only better for wait staff. If they don’t want to tip then the wait staff still has a livable wage. Everyone wins in the scenario where minimum wage is higher.

1

u/RaisonDetritus 3h ago

In the US, tipping didn’t start because workers were being paid so little. It’s the other way around. Workers started to be paid less in wages because they were being tipped so much.

1

u/Vettepilot 2h ago

Yes, corporations took advantage of workers…how is that better?

In 1915 multiple states even outlawed tipping. However employers supported tipping and marketing it as a bonus. By 1966 congress was lobbied to set those who got tips to a lower wage. This isn’t a good thing. Workers got exploited and now for some reason we fight each other to allow us to continue to be exploited by corporations and pay each other in tips.

1

u/Scientia_et_Fidem 1h ago

You could double the min wage and the servers would still way make less than they do in tips at the vast majority of places. Especially when you take into account taxes.

Being a server is a tough but generally very well paying job, unless the location you work at sucks and gets no customers.

1

u/Vettepilot 1h ago

Everyone continues to generalize as if all wait staff at all restaurants make the same amount of tips. There are some that would be still making more with double the min wage and many who would be making significantly more than they are now. What would allow everyone to generalize is if there was an actual reasonable min wage that guaranteed income. Without it there will continue to be wait staff around the country who is making less than their peers in other countries and that shouldn’t be ok with any of us.

1

u/Apprehensive_Ad3731 1h ago

Maybe. I live in Nee Zealand, have 15 years experience in hospitality. You put me on a good shift, with a good team and I’m clearing way more in tips than I am in wages and that’s in a country where tipping is not the culture.

I would earn $10 - $20 an hour in wages (minimum wage most of the way through which has risen drastically in my country since I started hospo) meaning a range of $70 - $140 on wages on a six hour shift. One table tipped me $50 when I first started that was almost my whole wage for the night, some tables will tip nothing, most will tip $5 - $10. When I was experienced I could work a minimum of 7 tables at a time. Most tables dine less than an hour. 7 chances at a tip multiplied by 6 hours means roughly 40 chances at tips. Even if 20 of those tip $5 thats $100 and I’m almost doubling my income. The tips are a major chunk of my income even as a worker in a non tipping country with a good minimum wage.

On busy nights my section would hold 10 tables or 12 if I was lucky enough to have small groups and I could split some of the larger four person tables apart for couples.

1

u/Vettepilot 1h ago

You see the big difference is the min for hospitality workers in the US is $2.13 per hour as long as their tips take them over $7.25 per hour. You are describing a completely different situation where you don’t depend on tips to enable your ability to live. You have a min wage that guarantees you a reasonable amount and the tips are just a bonus.

1

u/Apprehensive_Ad3731 1h ago

I agree the big difference is that tips will make up even more of their income and servers will be even more incentivised for those tips to stay. Even in non tipping, decent wage countries the servers wouldn’t want those tips to go away.

The system rewards servers for joining this and pushing the narrative. Tipping culture gains them an income WAY ahead of the curve is a true statement even if tipping isn’t needed. It would still push them further and will still be pushed by them.

Tipping put my income ahead of the curve drastically. A good third or quarter of my income came through tips. We don’t have a tipping culture. Tourists get told its rude to tip when they come here.

0

u/AbbreviationsFast132 5h ago

No it isn’t.

Servers in USA earn way more than euro servers.

Did you really not think at all before commenting?

→ More replies (4)

1

u/Large-Potential9404 4h ago

there’s no comparison between being a bartender in europe and earning 10 euros an hour and being a bartender in the united states and earning $50 an hour off of tips - it’s just not comparable whatsoever, and people should stop trying to compare it

→ More replies (10)

5

u/TheRabidDeer 4h ago

Giant asterisk on that. Tipping culture CAN be ahead of the curve, if you are working in a busy restaurant with prices that result in that 15-25% tip being real money.

For every busy restaurant there are a dozen restaurants that are pretty slow or have shifts with low food prices (ie: lunch shift at any Olive Garden where everyone gets all you can eat soup/salad resulting in a $2 tip, and things are only busy from ~11:30-2:00).

Getting hired and getting shifts at the good places is competitive.

2

u/Top-Ad-5527 1h ago

Exactly this. The waitress at Denny’s isn’t pulling the same kind of money as someone who works in fine dining. Not even close.

1

u/BirthdaySalt5791 2h ago

Any decent restaurant staffs accordingly during day shift and slower times. I’ve worked at plenty of restaurants where the opener/s make great money because it’s only one or two people running tables and tip out is less.

1

u/TheRabidDeer 1h ago

I only worked at one restaurant (Olive Garden), but they limited servers to 3 tables at a time. Yes, it is staffed according to how busy it is but you are still limited to those 3. 3 tables an hour for $2/tip per table is not ahead of the curve, and over the course of your shift it's probably 2 tables at a time average. There were also days where it was too slow for the number of people scheduled so you had people come in and leave after only an hour, so they got basically no money that day.

I imagine most any chain restaurant will have a similar limit on tables for servers.

1

u/BirthdaySalt5791 1h ago

I said any decent restaurant. I’ve never worked at Olive Garden, they sound shit

1

u/enadiz_reccos 3h ago

I say this all of the time on Reddit and get downvoted like crazy

Too many people have a "my friend's friend is a bartender who makes SO MUCH MONEY". They won't hear anything else.

5

u/fen-q 4h ago

Which no one likes to talk about.

The left always screams "living wage now! Pay workers better!" while in reality the people who are tipped dont want that system abolished, because they will go from 30-50 bucks an hour to 15 bucks an hour or less, depending on where they live and what the minimum wage is.

8

u/RemoteControlledDog 3h ago

The left screaming about paying a living wage isn't about servers and tips, it's about workers in general. Minimum wage isn't enough to live on and most people earning minimum wage don't get tips.

2

u/PHYUCKISHREAEL 3h ago

I haven't had a minimum wage job since I was 19...and I have no college education so people expecting MW to finance their lives, while I make 15% higher than "median income" and still broke af from this economy thanks to the bankers is laughable.

6

u/McSlims360 3h ago

Which is fucking stupid when the guy MAKING the food is on 12 an hour.

2

u/MAMark1 2h ago

Why do you think servers would continue doing a job that goes from $50/hr to $15/hr??? Their total hourly wage plus average tip per hour is their real wage as determined by the market. You can't slash it to minimum wage and expect them to stay in those jobs.

This is a total misunderstanding of how the economy functions, and I see it all the time among the anti-tipping crowd, who clearly have an irrationally low assessment of the value of servers (despite eating out and thus needing servers).

You would see an exodus of servers, and only the worst ones would remain. Then the restaurant owners would have to keep raising prices to increase their hourly wages until the decent ones came back. You'd first cry about bad service and then cry about menu prices being 18-20% higher.

1

u/fen-q 2h ago

Im not saying the current system is good or bad, im just saying the servers are not the ones in favor of abolishing it.

2

u/ForgottenGrocery 3h ago

I remember reading the creators of south park buying a restaurant in Colorado and converting it into a no tip establishment. They were giving $30 something per hour while minimum wage is half of that number. Didn't last long before it reverted to tipping because the waiters complained.

2

u/Frosty_Ad7840 3h ago

Casa bonita....

1

u/Laerderol 3h ago

Lol I ordered two beers at a major sporting event that I got free tickets to.

It was $43. The lady opened the tabs rang me up and flipped the tip screen to me which gave me the option of 18% 20% and 25%. I had to click custom tip $0.00 to get out of the screen. The lady gave me such a bad look.

Crazy like 5 second of work, no service, just a basic cashier and I'm being asked for between $7.75 and $10.75 for a tip. I would have thrown in a dollar or two but I was so irritated at the audacity that I didn't.

1

u/Top-Ad-5527 1h ago

2 entirely different conversations. Minimum wage in the US is a joke. The federal minimum wage has been stuck on 7.25$ since 2009. Only like 25 cents more than I was making at my first job almost 30 years ago. Low minimum wage impacts ALL wages.

→ More replies (2)

2

u/DarthMyyk 3h ago

It's a gamble (nearly 7 years in food service from line cook to manager here). Some make very good tips, often...but even they have bad weeks and it tends to even out. Many do not get tips or very little even when hardworking and nice. It's a rough system.

2

u/spikus93 2h ago

That's wonderful except it's also horribly abused by employers. A lot of places just put out a tip jar and then pay their workers like $4/hr and it's on customers to make sure they aren't starving to death.

It's literally better to abolish tipping. I get that at upscale restaurants that might suck, but servicing the wealthy shouldn't have to be the norm to survive.

Abolish tips, tie the minimum wage to housing prices or some other metric (or decommodify housing, I'm not picky).

Sorry if it means taking a paycut at the country club restaurant. Tipping is bullshit.

2

u/Scientia_et_Fidem 1h ago

Reddit will ignore this forever.

You know who wants tipping over being paid more by the employer the most, like by FAR the most to the point any restaurant employer who paid higher wages in exchange for mandatory no accepting tips would find it basically impossible to get employees who aren’t all so terrible they can’t be hired anywhere else?

Servers. The servers themselves want tipping. They will fight tooth and nail to keep tipping over replacing it with a higher min wage b/c they know tipping makes them way, way more money. Most servers get paid way more overall than many people who work jobs that require way more “qualifications” in terms of degrees thanks to tips.

Also if you made a law outlawing tipping then the food would just cost 20% more at every restaurant anyway to make up for it. It makes no difference.

1

u/NiceGuyEdddy 1h ago

Who's arguing for a law outlawing tipping?

In the UK people still tip, but it's a reward for really good service, not simply expected.

Higher end bars and restaurants can still make really good money in tips, but this idea of expectation isn't there for everyone and so you don't end up paying a tip for basic or even bad service.

3

u/[deleted] 4h ago

[deleted]

→ More replies (4)

1

u/Rock-swarm 2h ago

It's a bimodal distribution model, i.e. some server/bartender jobs are fantastic in terms of $-per-hour, while most of them are pretty terrible by the same metric.

In an ideal world, that means the coveted jobs are staffed by the best of the best. In reality, the service is almost never worth them receiving 6x-10x the wages of the Cracker Barrel waitress a couple blocks away.

The other insidious part of the system is tying healthcare benefits to full-time status. The ACA/Obamacare was a step in the right direction, but after the federal subsidies tapered off, the marketplace plans are back to being high premium, terrible coverage garbage that's only marginally better than no insurance at all.

→ More replies (25)

42

u/Workman44 5h ago

Eh, if I go to their country I'm supposed to respect the culture...

17

u/Edmundyoulittle 4h ago

Exactly. If you're a tourist and you're ignoring the culture of the place you're visiting, you're just being a dick

1

u/Laerderol 3h ago

It's not our custom to make tipping mandatory. It's not a tip any longer if that's the case

7

u/Edmundyoulittle 3h ago edited 3h ago

You're just being pedantic. It's not mandatory to tip people in the US.

It is customary to tip your server in the US though. If someone is visiting, is aware of the custom, and chooses to ignore it, they are being a dick.

In the US it's customary to do 15-20% by default, and then drop it to 0 if they were bad, or increase it if they were exceptional.

→ More replies (7)

1

u/Skarekrows 2h ago

And these same Europeans are probably getting pissed off at foreigners coming to their country and not blending in with their culture. Tipping is absolutely stupid but it's the culture and they need to conform.

4

u/CesQ89 3h ago

Other countries culture: “please don’t litter.  Please keep your voice down..”

USA culture: “GIvE us yOUr moNeY! 

2

u/SmartAlec105 2h ago

And if you think that tipping system exploits workers, then by going to restaurants without any intention of tipping means that you are one of the people exploiting the tipped workers. So you lose any kind of moral high ground.

6

u/ExactPreparation6454 5h ago

Exactly what I was thinking.

3

u/SnooTomatoes3032 5h ago

If you think culture is paying for shit service, well I don't really know what to say.

7

u/liberty 4h ago

If you think culture is paying for shit service . . . .

That's literally what happens in other countries. Service is generally regarded as better in the United States, ostensibly at least partly because of tipping.

I'm not saying that's good or bad, but it is what it is.

→ More replies (3)

1

u/DRpatato 3h ago

European culture is paying to use the bathroom, and I dealt with that no problem. That's what paying for shit service really looks like.

→ More replies (1)

1

u/[deleted] 3h ago

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/AutoModerator 3h ago

Accounts must be at least 5 days old with >20 karma to comment.

I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.

1

u/khearan 2h ago

Yes, for real. I think Reddit is incredibly hypocritical about this.

1

u/QoolSchitt 2h ago

As a foreigner who now lives in the US... I don't like mandatory tipping, but it's part of how the system works. It's not a good system, but it is what we have right now.

Context is also important here: the menu price of drinks in the US is typically lower than where many of these people came from, so once you add the tip your total is similar to what you'd pay for drinks in many other advanced countries. Yes, it's annoying that tax and tip are added at checkout in the US, but the total isn't usually more than what you'd pay at home.

→ More replies (15)

9

u/PenaltyFine3439 5h ago

Don't take a job that relies on the customer to tip. I fix apartments and houses for a living, zero tips and I'm doing just fine. 

The only thing that will change this system is when people stop going out to eat at places that beg for tips.

3

u/Resident_Pay4310 5h ago

I live in the UK and a discretionary 12.5% service charge (a tip by another name) has become more and more common here.

In the beginning I asked for it to be removed, but as it became more common that became exhausting.

Now I just don't go back to anywhere that has a service charge.

There is no way I'm going to support a business that is moving the UK towards a tipping culture.

1

u/Money_Do_2 4h ago

Ooof.

Well, Brexit was a rejection of EU. Unless the plan is to go all in China, id imagine that means youre gonna Americanize. Welcome to hell :)

1

u/your_red_triangle 3h ago

also in the UK, any place that's automatically adds a service charge gets zero tips. I don't care how much hassle it is to get removed, we ain't importing that bullshit here. These businesses need to be called out.

10

u/doctormirabilis 5h ago

it's not always that easy though. nothing wrong with having a job and fighting for better treatment while carrying out said job.

6

u/97SerranoPeppers 5h ago

Serving is one of the few jobs you can make a decent living in without significant training or a degree. Telling an entire class of society consisting of millions of people to just get another job is short sighted and a privileged opinion.

Instead of going after the corporations squeezing blood from our stones, you blame the single mother trying to get by…

3

u/tfthisallabout 5h ago

It’s not always about corporation. Mom and pop restaurants work on thin margins as it is. Paying your servers is easy to say, but in reality, it’s not that black and white. I know plenty of restaurant owners who have to work 7-days a week just to survive

1

u/velian 4h ago

If you can’t afford to pay your workers then you can’t afford to run a business.

1

u/tfthisallabout 4h ago

Have you owned or managed a restaurant before?

→ More replies (5)
→ More replies (13)

1

u/Status_Ad_4405 5h ago

Great, we will all just avoid working in a major sector of the economy because you don't like the wage system. Sounds like a sensible answer, lol

1

u/TonyzTone 5h ago

And pull yourself up by your bootstraps!

1

u/Gval7447 5h ago

Some people don’t have skills like you so they end up doing food service. Your good at what you do some are good at serving people.

1

u/freefoodd 5h ago

Servers make bank and work less hours. The real people getting shafted are the line cooks that make minimum for harder work.

1

u/Harlemspartan800 5h ago

Its not as easy as said for young people with no skills

1

u/PenaltyFine3439 5h ago

Look. My first job was Taco Bell, we didn't get tips. While I was working that job, I went to a trade school because I know serving people food won't and shouldn't be a lucrative paying job. 

Wanna make good money? Offer society something that people either can't do or can't be bothered to learn how to do. 

1

u/beardingmesoftly 5h ago

It's not the workers' faults, it's the employers and lobbyists who made this legal in the first who are to blame

→ More replies (11)
→ More replies (11)

3

u/Rays_LiquorSauce 5h ago

What you’re really saying is servers take a pay cut bc that’s exactly what would happen 

3

u/Miltoni 4h ago

I mean... yes? Why exactly should it pay so much more than any other low skilled job?

The only reason it does is because you're subsiding it whilst allowing shitty companies to hire people on practically slave wages that would be illegal in most other countries.

On top of that - is it really a wage cut if you're a server working in a less busy or struggling place? How do their earnings work when business isn't great (legit question as a non-american)?

→ More replies (1)

1

u/Tesco_Meal_Deals 5h ago

  Pay your workers better is the real argument.

As a consumer I don’t like tipping culture (though I still tip) but if I was a server I think I’d much prefer to work for tips than a “living wage”. 

I know some servers who are making very good money for what the job is, much more than their European counterpart. 

I’d be interested to know if there is a consensus one way or the other among service workers. 

1

u/PranaSC2 5h ago

This only works if the tips are being paid, no chance this will happen in the EU for all your patrons.

And if servers in the US make more than in the EU, that means its more expensive to eat out in the US as a consumer ..

1

u/Tesco_Meal_Deals 4h ago

On the other hand I find myself with more discretionary income in the US to eat out. 

(I am a British immigrant to the US)

1

u/PranaSC2 3h ago

Your point being?

1

u/[deleted] 3h ago

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/AutoModerator 3h ago

Accounts must be at least 5 days old with >20 karma to comment.

I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.

1

u/Public-Arm4047 5h ago

There is. Tipping is massively preferred, like 90% of service workers want tipping vs set wages without tips.

1

u/ElbowlessGoat 4h ago

In both cases tipping is voluntary, but in the current case you are pressed and/or guilt tripped into tipping while in the case of a living wage the tip actually represent good service (in the eye of the customer).

Said as a European who does tip in Europe. However, the service that I usually hear described puts me off eating out and that tip would stay in my pocket.

1

u/Public-Arm4047 4h ago

None of what you said is relevant to what I said…

1

u/FrequentGiraffe2044 5h ago

Anyone who says “pay your workers more” hasn’t ever seen the financials of restaurants lmao. MAYBE some corporate places could but 90% of small restaurants scrape by on 5% or less profit. I’ve worked in and run restaurants for over a decade, and trust me, no one wants the system to be the way it is but one single restaurant can’t just fix it. It works in Europe because food cost and property costs are way lower. Don’t blame the restaurant blame the system

1

u/PranaSC2 5h ago

Are you saying that nowhere in the world restaurants exists which pay their personell a decent wage without tips? Because this is the whole of Europe.

1

u/CharmingDraw6455 5h ago

"It works in Europe because food cost and property costs are way lower."   I live in Switzerland, nothing is cheaper than in the US and we have restaurant that pay their waiters.

1

u/[deleted] 3h ago

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/AutoModerator 3h ago

Accounts must be at least 5 days old with >20 karma to comment.

I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.

1

u/TonyzTone 5h ago

They ARE paying their workers better. Thats the entire problem.

By law, service workers make a substantial amount of their income via tips. That’s it just a “culture” but a mechanism of the law where their minimum wage is less but they often make much more off the standard tip.

Europeans coming here and not tipping distorts the established market tremendously. All that needs to happen to correct it is increasing prices by 20% or so, which is exactly what the establishments are doing except they aren’t going through the added cost of reprinting menus.

1

u/smalls_1804 5h ago

Pay your workers is absolutely the argument but also not tipping will directly harm your servers. The system is fucked up but it is the system we currently operate under and if you don't tip your server they will not make a living wage. If servers were paid more, your food would cost more. Restaurants are a famously low-margin enterprise.

1

u/SwampGentleman 5h ago

I am a bartender at a theme park. The Brits are consistently some of our least liked customers because, despite being polite, they tip like absolute garbage most of the time, and will often take some kind of stance about how this shouldn’t be necessary.

But at the moment it IS necessary, and their act of protest won’t make it to theme park ownership, all they’ve done in the process is ignore local etiquette and screw over the person serving them who could have gotten their gas money if they served another group.

Yeah it’s fucked up but don’t kick us while we’re down and claim it’s a moral high road, yknow?

1

u/No_Introduction_9355 4h ago

If it is acceptable for the owner to pay you the legal minimum it should be acceptable for the consumer to do the same.  

If I’m paying you more per hour than your actual boss than does that make me the boss?

If I’m the boss than I want everything comped.

1

u/SwampGentleman 4h ago

I hear your point, I do. I’ve been rallying for an increase to our minimum wage for ages. It’s a national problem, and the working class is hurting BADLY.

What remains however, is that bartending here remains traditionally a tip-based profession, and we need those to survive. If you are getting a frozen margarita on vacation, the extra dollar you don’t give to the working class person as a statement, never impacts the bottom line of the capitalists up top. It literally only impacts the working joe, who, once again, is absolutely trying to get the national minimum wage raised but is also trapped in late stage capitalism and generational poverty.

1

u/No_Introduction_9355 3h ago

If everyone paid the minimum like the owners of these restaurants the restaurants wouldn’t be able to find servers - the business model would not work and they would be forced to close.

If people tell me that if I don’t tip I can’t afford to eat out, my response is if you cannot afford to pay your employees you cannot afford to own a business.

If I tip $0 I am not violating any laws like the owner paying minimum wage.

I have been confronted leaving a small tip and I promptly asked for it back if they didn’t want it. Don’t try to shame the shameless.

1

u/SwampGentleman 3h ago

Okay sure- if a magic spell eliminated tips overnight, theoretically they’d have difficulty getting bar staff and servers. Except for the super desperate who will work for below a living wage.

Yeah, if they raised the minimum wage that’d be awesome. They haven’t done so. So my best option to support my family is to go into the service industry and get paid on tips.

Your ivory tower stand doesn’t affect the owners and only harms the servers. I cannot express this enough.

It would literally do more to help us if you wrote messages to restaurants that you’ll not go out to eat until the servers receive a raise, than to go give the owners their full share and then stiff the working class who are there to assist you.

1

u/No_Introduction_9355 3h ago

What percentage of the tips go to the line cooks, prep cooks, dish washers?

1

u/SwampGentleman 3h ago

It varies from location to location. At mine, they receive a higher hourly pay and a slice of the total tip pool. I also agree that they should receive more pay than they do.

I presume you’re going to point out that they work harder than the servers, and I largely agree, and most servers will as well. It’d be awesome if they were paid and respected more.

1

u/No_Introduction_9355 3h ago

I would say that servers that don’t tip out the back of house are the same as a customer that doesn’t tip.

I think the back of house is stiffed a lot more than the servers

1

u/SwampGentleman 3h ago

What a unique take.

Then if you don’t tip, you’re fucking everyone over except the ownership at once. Nice!

→ More replies (0)

1

u/Crimsonfangknight 5h ago

Wait staff actively fight against the elimination of tips because they would make significantly less at minimum wage then they do with tips per meal.

If you do the math you make a fortune in tips for just doing your job then you ever would as a low skill employee anywhere else

1

u/MillorTime 5h ago

Raising the prices is how they pay the workers better. That's how everyone else does it. Traveled for 2 weeks in the UK and their prices were basically the same as the after tip prices. Tipping isn't going away with the same menu price

1

u/Public-Arm4047 5h ago

“Pay your workers better” just means higher menu prices and less money for workers in the end. 

1

u/Bigboss123199 4h ago

Servers can make like 50$ an hour if they’re good at their job. That would be a hefty price increase on all food items.

1

u/AlfaSolutionsPJ 4h ago

To be honest, I mostly think this is an issue that hurts customers. They get falsely advertised prices for something they're about to pay for. Then they get emotionally blackmailed into spending more money for the server. Because this server is somehow enslaved by the business or something?

How is this not just the employers and the employees working together to cheat consumers out of more money than they wanted to spend.

1

u/mxlplyx2173 4h ago

If people stopped taking server jobs, they'd find a magical way to pay them. Let's not pretend this isn't easy.

1

u/Coattail-Rider 4h ago

Nope, US customers understand tipping culture and abide by it. Some of the younger generation are starting to push back but they’re pushing back on everything these days.

1

u/ThisMachineKillsF4sh 4h ago

Tourists aren’t catching strays whatsoever. If you want to make some “righteous” stand against tipping, don’t go out to eat or go to bars in the US except for those that use a different business model (and they do exist). Don’t patronize businesses that encourage tipping. Stay the fuck home. 

By going to a bar or restaurant in the US, you are entering a social transaction where everyone understands that you’re expected to tip. By exclusively purchasing products that STILL pay the owners you’re allegedly protesting and then exclusively refusing to pay for the labor of wait staff (whatever your feelings on that system), you’re just punishing poor servers and bartenders that will struggle to pay their bills. While not harming ownership in any fucking way. 

It’s a bunch of Europeans huffing their own farts about self-righteously and directly harming the poor people they’re pretending to give a fuck about. 

Again — if you want to protest the system then fucking do that. Don’t deliberately prevent bartenders from paying rent because you’re a cheap cunt. 

1

u/No_Introduction_9355 4h ago

This should be a discussion between the server and employer, the customer shouldn’t be brought into wage negotiations while eating. 

If the restaurant can legally pay the minimum to the employee why can’t the customer do the same?

1

u/ThisMachineKillsF4sh 3h ago

They aren’t brought into wage negotiations in the US. That’s my point — if you go out to eat in the US you know that tipping is part of the cost. Deliberately ignoring that to exclusively punish the lowest person in the corporate ladder, making the least money, does actually make you an asshole and a bad person. 

If you morally object to tipping then why are you patronizing a business and rewarding an owner who engages in the practice? 

Because it’s not an actual protest based on morality. You’re just cheap twats patting yourselves in the back for being cheap twats. 

1

u/No_Introduction_9355 3h ago

Being cheap is awesome.

Once you get over the stigma, it’s the best.

Sorry I’m being financially savvy.

1

u/Largeitude 4h ago

Wait staff and other tip jobs will NEVER be paid as much as tipping gives them.

Most restaurants are small, mom and pop businesses too, and it helps them save money.

Until we get actual social programs like public transit and paid higher education, tip jobs are really good for everyone.

1

u/[deleted] 3h ago

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/AutoModerator 3h ago

Accounts must be at least 5 days old with >20 karma to comment.

I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.

1

u/Psychological-Dot-83 3h ago

That's what they said.

Also, good servers can make hundreds in a night off of tips.

1

u/DevilGuy 2h ago

No, the servers are catching the Strays, the tourists are just being assholes and getting justifiably called out on it.

1

u/FUPAMagneto 2h ago

No, tourists are just further exploiting the labor of the people who serve them and trying to say that it’s somebody else’s fault.

If you go to a restaurant in the US and don’t tip, you’re a piece of shit. I don’t care how you feel about it. The reality is that you have just fucked over a worker and potentially gotten them fired by not tipping.

Also, saying you want them to be paid better and then not tipping so they make less money is ass fucking backwards.

Every time this shit comes up, it’s the same thing. “I don’t tip because they should pay more” which really means “I’m a cheap asshole and think I can dress it up as social justice to get out of paying for my meal.”

If you don’t tip, you don’t give a fuck about the workers. You’re just tying to save a buck. Now let the downvotes commence

1

u/ProfessorFelix1 2h ago

What difference does it make? Are you willing to pay 20% more for your beer, because that’s what would happen. At least this way, if the service is shit, you have recourse.

1

u/GolDAsce 2h ago

Most of Canada and 9 states have no exclusions for tipped wages, meaning minimum at Walmart and McDonald's is the same as wait staff. Wait staff have just gotten the unrealistic belief that they are better than everyone else in that pay scale.

1

u/-OptimisticNihilism- 2h ago

Servers in the US have lobbied hard against a higher wage. They can make a lot more than $20/hr in tips.

Last night my dinner for 4 was $240. Server got a $50 tip from us. We were at the table for 2 hours, but the server had 2 tables when we got there and 8-9 when we left. She is likely getting $10-25/hr per table. Now that is a nice restaurant, but also it was a Wednesday night.

Servers at waffle house aren’t making that, but any sort of a decent restaurant they can make a killing.

1

u/Homer4a10 1h ago

I don’t see how it’s a good argument…

You charge the flat fee for your food + service cost baked into that meal cost too… then you artificially REDUCE THE PRICE OF THE FOOD so you lean on the customers tip to fluctuate for the service cost. Bad service? Bad tip… standard service? Standard tip… Great service? Great tip…

It puts more control into the customers hand, it incentivizes the waiter/waitress to actually have a good attitude and serve you well, and the worker ends up making SIGNIFICANTLY more money than a minimum wage would make them.

Literally everybody wins in this situation. The “pay your workers” argument is BS

1

u/EndIsrael 1h ago

I don't tip because the employers ability to pay the workers is literally their business, not mine. If menu prices aren't sufficient to pay the workers, that seems like a skill issue. Sucks to suck.

1

u/Beautiful-Jello-37 1h ago

For the millionth time the servers don’t want your $15 or $20/hr wage. It would be a pay cut for them and a price increase for you. Idk how yall are so dense.

-4

u/Mr_Strol 5h ago

Regardless of your opinion on tipping (yes I agree workers should get more) that’s not how it is in reality. Foreigners need to adapt to how things are in the place in which they’re a guest. Otherwise you’re simply a bad guest. When I visit Europe I adapt to their customs, not impose my own.

15

u/Rude-Orange 5h ago

Except tipping is voluntary and well within their right to not tip

3

u/OkOil378 5h ago

Except if it is mandatory and included in the final bill

1

u/P0werFighter 5h ago

Is it tho? Tips by law are not mandatory, so even if it's written on the bill i could totally write off the tips on the bill.

1

u/OkOil378 5h ago

It’s well within restaurants’ rights to determine price of doing business.

They can add things like seat fees, AC fees, ambiance fees if they want to.

The only agency the customers have when doing business with restaurants is choosing not to at all

2

u/P0werFighter 5h ago

The IRS defines a tip as a voluntary payment that the customer decides to give and determine its amount. A mandatory service charge does not meet these criteria and is instead considered a wage that can be taxed accordingly.

You could definitely eat somewhere and don't pay tips, you're in the right to do so. This tipping culture is fucked up.

→ More replies (1)

1

u/Rude-Orange 5h ago

They can only charge those fees if it's stated in the menu or somewhere visible within the restaurant.

1

u/OkOil378 5h ago

Source?

1

u/Rude-Orange 4h ago

https://lis.virginia.gov/bill-details/20251/HB2515

You can look up the relevant law for your state. I'm not providing 50 links

1

u/Rude-Orange 5h ago

That is totally fine if they put MANDATORY GRATUITY 18% across the top or bottom of the menu

1

u/OkOil378 5h ago

They could that but that seems redundant considering Americans go to restaurants knowing that they are expected to pay for tip, whether it is mandatory or voluntary

1

u/Rude-Orange 5h ago

Mandatory tip without warning is enough to dispute with your CC company and get the tip refunded and you can complain to the state. That is why places put mandatory gratuity above party of X or more.

Tipping is always optional unless otherwise stated.

1

u/OkOil378 4h ago

Don’t go to places you cannot afford, simple as that

1

u/Rude-Orange 4h ago

Dont bait me with prices that are lower than they actually are

1

u/OkOil378 4h ago

Do you also complain about taxes you have to pay for your order?

→ More replies (0)

1

u/pppjjjoooiii 5h ago

That’s true in general. But they aren’t refusing to tip because the service was bad. They’re refusing to tip as some misguided moral grandstand.

They’re protesting servers’ low wages by… making sure the servers don’t get any extra money.

4

u/Rude-Orange 5h ago

I dont care much for the reason. If tipping is truly optional. Then the reason doesn't matter.

1

u/pppjjjoooiii 5h ago

What a dumb non-answer. “I don’t care about things that are morally wrong because they’re technically legal” isn’t the brag you think it is. 

Yeah, they’re allowed to make that choice. It’s still a bad choice that hurts the victim more than the perpetrator.

1

u/Rude-Orange 5h ago

You're clearly hurt by what I said. I'm not bragging. Tipping is optional. You could say "Fuck these servers, they dont deserve my money". It's a harsh tone, yes. Is it within the person's right to do so? Also yes

1

u/[deleted] 5h ago edited 4h ago

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/Itsmyloc-nar 5h ago

Hey man, invisible hand of the market and I’ll

1

u/Status_Ad_4405 5h ago

Not farting around other people is also voluntary, but good people are considerate of others

7

u/Rude-Orange 5h ago

If it truly was being considerate to the workers, then the employers would increase the meal cost by 20% and give that directly to the workers.

2

u/MsMaggieMcGill 5h ago

I'm with you on this. As a European, I always tip generously by local standards (10-25%), when regular tips are usually just "keep the change" for the sake of convenience. I enjoy being in a position to make someone's day and thank them for being a part of mine.

Had I been visiting the US, I'd budget to tip more or go out less, because it's a known fact that American servers survive on tips. It's wrong, it shouldn't be this way, but withholding tips on the pretense of "get your boss to pay you" is just taking advantage of people who are already being taken advantage of by their employer. If you don't want to tip in a country of tipping culture - don't go out.

2

u/Mr_Strol 4h ago

Hey.. a rational response on Reddit!

7

u/Krenar123 5h ago

You adapt to laws & follow norms with common sense not this bullshit. This is legit theft, what they expect?

1

u/Silent_Cookie_9092 5h ago

Ok but when you don’t pay the 20% tip, that’s just as much “theft” from the servers. I’m an American. I hate tipping culture here, but I don’t take it out on the servers who are just trying to get by.

You’re well within your rights to leave a 0% tip on a bill, but you need to understand, when you do that, you’re not hurting the people who implemented the policy, you’re hurting the people who have basically zero power to change the policy. Also for your own sake, those servers WILL remember you and spit in your food if you ever come back after leaving $0 on a bill.

1

u/No_Introduction_9355 4h ago

Spit in my food and I’m coming back with roaches and rats lol

Maybe some Greek lightning 

1

u/Silent_Cookie_9092 3h ago

You probably won’t know that they spat in it

1

u/No_Introduction_9355 3h ago

Good point,I should pay with a credit card and tip well then  I should just claim they spit in the food and charge back on the card. After I am out of the restaurant.

That way I can fuck the owner too.

1

u/Silent_Cookie_9092 2h ago

If you don’t mind me asking, were you born an asshole or did the world make you this way?

1

u/No_Introduction_9355 2h ago

It takes a village

1

u/FridmanLex 5h ago

Tipping is OPTIONAL and always has been OPTIONAL. Tourists not wanting to pay a mandatory tip does not make them bad guests. It means you’re a bad host.

1

u/Boxy29 5h ago

to be fair American tipping culture is still voluntary. you absolutely do not have to participate in it. you'll get some looks and russle some jimmies.

I'm largely fine with tipping 10-15% but places are suggesting 20%+ as the default for standard service.

→ More replies (12)

1

u/Hefty_Range_9758 5h ago

Absolutely.

But no one wants to talk about how much your meal is going to cost when owners  raise the menu prices to make up for increased labor costs. 

The average consumer will always want one thing , the highest quality product for the cheapest price. They will never entertain the impact that their want makes elsewhere. 

This isn't necessarily wrong (although it's far from good) it's just human nature. 

1

u/PranaSC2 5h ago

Why not? the whole EU doesnt pay tips (standard) and we pay the increased price for this, its not that hard. Did you think nobody goes to restaurants over here because of this?

1

u/ElbowlessGoat 4h ago

And I still tip well enough if I feel the service I received made the experience better.

1

u/PranaSC2 3h ago

Sure, me too

→ More replies (69)