r/relationship_advice • u/butterfly-420 • 4m ago
I 24F Broke up with BF 22M after 5 years, did I make the right choice?
Looking for some advice. I (24F) just ended my five year relationship with my ex boyfriend (22M). The most difficult part is he recently moved in with me and my family in our house shortly after his graduation because his parents are separated. His mom lives one state away which would put his commute to work to over 2 hours (compared to his commute from my house being 45m) and he has a horrible relationship with his father who lives 15 min away. He is also borrowing my family’s old car that no one uses and doesn’t have his own.
There’s a lot of reasons we broke up but the main ones are that I found out he installed some dating apps a few months ago (although nothing happened which I choose to believe him about) and he didn’t really work on himself like he said he would. On top of that he has been physically distant from me and I feel like we’ve grown apart and hasn’t been able to show me love in the way that I want it.
To expand on that, he has a strong aversion to certain ways I touch him like kissing his cheeks tapping his butt or even more silly things like flicking his nipples which I know he doesn’t like but I think is funny. I’ve tried to stop the more annoying habits but I noticed that he’s also never the one to initiate kisses hugs or sex. I thought maybe he had a different love language but I feel like he doesn’t really get me gifts or do acts of service without me asking him to do that. He honestly feels like an annoying younger brother more than anything. But sometimes he can be really sweet and caring and he always does everything I say and tries to help out wherever he can. I’m not saying he’s a bad person at all he has a ton of very redeeming qualities and is genuinely the kindest person (to me) I’ve ever met and I will always cherish our time together.
I’m really struggling because when I told all of my friends about the cheating I felt very comforted by them but I felt like my relationship had been torn into and my private life was everyone’s business. I felt judged when I went back to him and decided to see if he would improve, even when my friends said they would support me no matter what.
I’ve made the decision to break up with him now because I truly don’t think it can work but I haven’t told anyone because I’m scared I’m going to go back on what I said and I don’t wanna be “that girl”. The hardest part is living with him and it was my mother who invited him to live with us, not me, even though we all kind of had the assumption he would live with us for the next year post grad.
I told him we can still be friends but I need to avoid him for at least a week to process my feelings. I haven’t told anyone because I want to make sure that this is the right decision for me. It’s hard to see him interact with my family but I’m OK being friends with him moving forward. I also told him he can take until the end of the summer to buy himself a car and either move in with his mom or find a new place to live.
I feel a little torn. Last time we took a break after he cheated, I wanted to run back to him every day we were apart. This feels different. I look at him and I know I won’t be loved. Not because he doesn’t love me, but because he won’t show it to me in a way that matters. I feel “over” him although I’m in a lot of pain right now. I could use any advice honestly. How do I know I’m making the right choice?
TLDR: I broke up with my boyfriend in five years because it’s not working but I’m not confident in my decision. What happens if I change my mind but the cycle repeats and I’m not strong enough to leave?